Modeling Linkage Disequilibrium Increases Accuracy of Polygenic Risk Scores

Bjarni J. Vilhjálmsson,Jian Yang,Hilary K. Finucane,Alexander Gusev,Sara Lindström,Stephan Ripke,Giulio Genovese,Po-Ru Loh,Gaurav Bhatia,Ron Do,Tristan J. Hayeck,Hong-Hee Won,Sekar Kathiresan,Michele T. Pato,Carlos N. Pato,Rulla M. Tamimi,Eli A. Stahl,Noah Zaitlen,Bogdan Paşaniuc,Gillian M. Belbin,Eimear E. Kenny,Mikkel Heide Schierup,Philip L. De Jager,Nikolaos A. Patsopoulos,Steven A. McCarroll,Mark J. Daly,Shaun Purcell,Daniel I. Chasman,Benjamin M. Neale,Michael E. Goddard,Peter M. Visscher,Peter Kraft,Nick Patterson,Alkes L. Price,Aiden Corvin,James T.R. Walters,Kai-How Farh,Peter Holmans,Phil Lee,Brendan Bulik‐Sullivan,David A. Collier,Hailiang Huang,Tune H. Pers,Ingrid Agartz,Esben Agerbo,Margot Albus,Madeline Alexander,Farooq Amin,Silviu‐Alin Bacanu,Martin Begemann,Richard A. Belliveau,Judit Bene,Sarah E. Bergen,Elizabeth Bevilacqua,Tim B. Bigdeli,Donald W. Black,Richard Bruggeman,Nancy G. Buccola,Randy L. Buckner,William Byerley,Wiepke Cahn,Guiqing Cai,Dominique Campion,Rita M. Cantor,Vaughan J. Carr,Noa Carrera,Stanley V. Catts,Kimberly Chambert,Raymond C. K. Chan,Ronald Y.L. Chen,Eric Chen,Wei Cheng,Eric F.C. Cheung,Siow Ann Chong,C. Robert Cloninger,David Cohen,Nadine Cohen,Paul Cormican,Nick Craddock,James J. Crowley,David Curtis,Michael Davidson,Kenneth L. Davis,Franziska Degenhardt,Jurgen Del-Favero,Lynn E. DeLisi,Ditte Demontis,Dimitris Dikeos,Timothy G. Dinan,Srdjan Djurovic,Gary Donohoe,Elodie Drapeau,Jubao Duan,Frank Dudbridge,Naser Durmishi,Peter Eichhammer,Johan G. Eriksson,Valentina Escott‐Price,Laurent Essioux,Ayman H. Fanous,Martilias S. Farrell,Josef Frank,Lude Franke,Robert Freedman,Nelson B. Freimer,Marion Friedl,Joseph I. Friedman,Menachem Fromer,Lyudmila Georgieva,Elliot S. Gershon,Ina Giegling,Paola Giusti-Rodrguez,Stephanie Godard,Jacqueline I. Goldstein,V. E. Golimbet,Srihari Gopal,Jacob Gratten,Jakob Grove,Lieuwe de Haan,Christian Hammer,Marian L. Hamshere,Mark Hansen,Thomas Hansen,Vahram Haroutunian,Annette M. Hartmann,Frans Henskens,Stefan Herms,Joel N. Hirschhorn,Per Hoffmann,Andrea Hofman,Mads V. Hollegaard,David M. Hougaard,Nakao Iwata,Inge Joa,Antonio Julià,René S. Kahn,Luba Kalaydjieva,Sena Karachanak-Yankova,Juha Karjalainen,David Kavanagh,Matthew C. Keller,Brian Kelly,James L. Kennedy,Andrey Khrunin,Yunjung Kim,Jānis Kloviņš,James A. Knowles,Bettina Konte,Vaidutis Kučinskas,Zita Aušrelė Kučinskienė,Hana Kuzelova-Ptackova,Anna K. Kähler,Claudine Laurent,Jimmy Lee Chee Keong,S. Hong Lee,Sophie E. Legge,Bernard Lerer,Miaoxin Li,Tao Li,Kung-Yee Liang,Jeffrey A. Lieberman,Svetlana Limborska,Carmel M. Loughland,Jan Lubiński,Jouko Lnnqvist,Milan Maçek,Patrik K. E. Magnusson,Brion S. Maher,Wolfgang Maier,Jacques Mallet,Sara Marsal,Manuel Mattheisen,Morten Mattingsdal,Robert W. McCarley,Colm McDonald,Andrew M. McIntosh,Sandra Meier,Carin J. Meijer,Béla Melegh,Ingrid Melle,Raquelle I. Mesholam‐Gately,Andres Metspalu,Patricia T. Michie,Lili Milani,Vihra Milanova,Younes Mokrab,Derek W. Morris,Ole Mors,Preben Bo Mortensen,Kieran C. Murphy,Robin M. Murray,Inez Myin‐Germeys,Bertram Mller-Myhsok,Mari Nelis,Igor Nenadić,Deborah A. Nertney,Gerald Nestadt,Kristin K. Nicodemus,Liene Ņikitina-Zaķe,Laura Nisenbaum,Annelie Nordin,Eadbhard O’Callaghan,Colm Ó'Dúshláine,Francis O’Neill,Sang‐Yun Oh,Ann Olincy,Line Olsen,Jim van Os,Christos Pantelis,George N. Papadimitriou,Sergi Papiol,Elena Parkhomenko,Tiina Paunio,Milica Pejović-Milovančević,Diana O. Perkins,Olli Pietilinen,Jonathan Pimm,Andrew Pocklington,John Powell,Ann E. Pulver,Digby Quested,Henrik Berg Rasmussen,Abraham Reichenberg,Mark Reimers,Alexander Richards,Joshua L. Roffman,Panos Roussos,Douglas M. Ruderfer,Veikko Salomaa,Alan R. Sanders,Ulrich Schall,Christian Schubert,Thomas G. Schulze,Sibylle G. Schwab,Edward M. Scolnick,Rodney J. Scott,Larry J. Seidman,Jianxin Shi,Engilbert Sigurðsson,Teimuraz Silagadze,Jeremy M. Silverman,Kang Sim,Petr Slominsky,Jordan W. Smoller,Hon‐Cheong So,Chris C. A. Spencer,Hreinn Stefánsson,Stacy Steinberg,Elisabeth Stögmann,Richard E. Straub,Eric Strengman,Jana Strohmaier,T. Scott Stroup,Mythily Subramaniam,Jaana Suvisaari,Dragan M. Švrakić,Jin P. Szatkiewicz,Erik Sderman,Srinivas Thirumalai,Draga Toncheva,Paul A. Tooney,Sarah Tosato,Juha Veijola,John L. Waddington,Dermot Walsh,Dai Wang,Qiang Wang,Bradley T. Webb,Mark Weiser,Dieter B. Wildenauer,Nigel Williams,Stephanie Williams,Stephanie H. Witt,Aaron R. Wolen,Emily H.M. Wong,Brandon Wormley,Jing Qin Wu,Hualin Simon Xi,Clement C. Zai,Xuebin Zheng,Fritz Zimprich,Naomi R. Wray,Kāri Stefánsson,Rolf Adolfsson,Ole A. Andreassen,Douglas Blackwood,Elvira Bramon,Joseph D. Buxbaum,Anders D. Børglum,Sven Cichon,Ariel Darvasi,Enrico Domenici,Hannelore Ehrenreich,Tõnu Esko,Pablo V. Gejman,Michael Gill,Hugh Gurling,Christina M. Hultman,Assen Jablensky,Erik Jönsson,Kenneth S. Kendler,George Kirov,Jo Knight,Todd Lencz,Douglas F. Levinson,Qingqin S. Li,Jing Liu,Anil K. Malhotra,Andrew McQuillin,Jennifer L. Moran,Bryan Mowry,Markus M. Nthen,Roel A. Ophoff,Michael J. Owen,Aarno Palotie,Tracey L. Petryshen,Daniëlle Posthuma,Marcella Rietschel,Brien P. Riley,Dan Rujescu,Pak C. Sham,Pamela Sklar,David St Clair,Daniel R. Weinberger,Jens R. Wendland,Thomas Werge,Patrick F. Sullivan,Michael C. O’Donovan,David J. Hunter,Muriel A. Adank,Habibul Ahsan,Kristiina Aittomäki,Laura Baglietto,Sonja I. Berndt,Carl Blomquist,Federico Canzian,Jenny Chang‐Claude,Stephen J. Chanock,Laura Crisponi,Kamila Czene,Norbert Dahmen,Isabel dos‐Santos‐Silva,Douglas F. Easton,A. Heather Eliassen,Jonine D. Figueroa,Olivia Fletcher,Montserrat García-Closas,Mia M. Gaudet,Lorna J. Gibson,Christopher A. Haiman,Per Hall,Aditi Hazra,Rebecca Hein,Brian E. Henderson,Albert Hofman,John L. Hopper,Astrid Irwanto,Mattias Johansson,Rudolf Kaaks,Muhammad G. Kibriya,Peter Lichtner,Eiliv Lund,Enes Makalic,Alfons Meindl,Hanne Meijers‐Heijboer,Bertram Müller‐Myhsok,Taru Muranen,Heli Nevanlinna,Petra H. Peeters,Julian Peto,Ross L. Prentice,Nazneen Rahman,María José Sánchez,Daniel F. Schmidt,Rita K. Schmutzler,Melissa C. Southey,Ruth C. Travis,Clare Turnbull,André G. Uitterlinden,Rob B. van der Luijt,Quinten Waisfisz,Zhaoming Wang,Alice S. Whittemore,Rose Yang,Zheng Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2015.09.001

2015-01-01

Abstract:Polygenic risk scores have shown great promise in predicting complex disease risk and will become more accurate as training sample sizes increase. The standard approach for calculating risk scores involves linkage disequilibrium (LD)-based marker pruning and applying a p value threshold to association statistics, but this discards information and can reduce predictive accuracy. We introduce LDpred, a method that infers the posterior mean effect size of each marker by using a prior on effect sizes and LD information from an external reference panel. Theory and simulations show that LDpred outperforms the approach of pruning followed by thresholding, particularly at large sample sizes. Accordingly, predicted R(2) increased from 20.1% to 25.3% in a large schizophrenia dataset and from 9.8% to 12.0% in a large multiple sclerosis dataset. A similar relative improvement in accuracy was observed for three additional large disease datasets and for non-European schizophrenia samples. The advantage of LDpred over existing methods will grow as sample sizes increase.