A Comparison of Ten Polygenic Score Methods for Psychiatric Disorders Applied Across Multiple Cohorts

Guiyan Ni,Jian Zeng,Joana A. Revez,Ying Wang,Zhili Zheng,Tian Ge,Restuadi Restuadi,Jacqueline Kiewa,Dale R. Nyholt,Jonathan R.I. Coleman,Jordan W. Smoller,Jian Yang,Peter M. Visscher,Naomi R. Wray,Stephan Ripke,Benjamin M. Neale,Aiden Corvin,James T.R. Walters,Kai-How Farh,Peter A. Holmans,Phil Lee,Brendan Bulik-Sullivan,David A. Collier,Hailiang Huang,Tune H. Pers,Ingrid Agartz,Esben Agerbo,Margot Albus,Madeline Alexander,Farooq Amin,Silviu A. Bacanu,Martin Begemann,Richard A. Belliveau,Judit Bene,Sarah E. Bergen,Elizabeth Bevilacqua,Tim B. Bigdeli,Donald W. Black,Richard Bruggeman,Nancy G. Buccola,Randy L. Buckner,William Byerley,Wiepke Cahn,Guiqing Cai,Dominique Campion,Rita M. Cantor,Vaughan J. Carr,Noa Carrera,Stanley V. Catts,Kimberley D. Chambert,Raymond C.K. Chan,Ronald Y.L. Chen,Eric Y.H. Chen,Wei Cheng,Eric F.C. Cheung,Siow Ann Chong,C. Robert Cloninger,David Cohen,Nadine Cohen,Paul Cormican,Nick Craddock,James J. Crowley,Michael Davidson,Kenneth L. Davis,Franziska Degenhardt,Jurgen Del Favero,Ditte Demontis,Dimitris Dikeos,Timothy Dinan,Srdjan Djurovic,Gary Donohoe,Elodie Drapeau,Jubao Duan,Frank Dudbridge,Naser Durmishi,Peter Eichhammer,Johan Eriksson,Valentina Escott-Price,Laurent Essioux,Ayman H. Fanous,Martilias S. Farrell,Josef Frank,Lude Franke,Robert Freedman,Nelson B. Freimer,Marion Friedl,Joseph I. Friedman,Menachem Fromer,Giulio Genovese,Lyudmila Georgieva,Ina Giegling,Paola Giusti-Rodríguez,Stephanie Godard,Jacqueline I. Goldstein,Vera Golimbet,Srihari Gopal,Jacob Gratten,Lieuwe de Haan,Christian Hammer,Marian L. Hamshere,Mark Hansen,Thomas Hansen,Vahram Haroutunian,Annette M. Hartmann,Frans A. Henskens,Stefan Herms,Joel N. Hirschhorn,Per Hoffmann,Andrea Hofman,Mads V. Hollegaard,David M. Hougaard,Masashi Ikeda,Inge Joa,Antonio Julià,René S. Kahn,Luba Kalaydjieva,Sena Karachanak-Yankova,Juha Karjalainen,David Kavanagh,Matthew C. Keller,James L. Kennedy,Andrey Khrunin,Yunjung Kim,Janis Klovins,James A. Knowles,Bettina Konte,Vaidutis Kucinskas,Zita Ausrele Kucinskiene,Hana Kuzelova-Ptackova,Anna K. Kähler,Claudine Laurent,Jimmy Lee,S. Hong Lee,Sophie E. Legge,Bernard Lerer,Miaoxin Li,Tao Li,Kung-Yee Liang,Jeffrey Lieberman,Svetlana Limborska,Carmel M. Loughland,Jan Lubinski,Jouko Lönnqvist,Milan Macek,Patrik K.E. Magnusson,Brion S. Maher,Wolfgang Maier,Jacques Mallet,Sara Marsal,Manuel Mattheisen,Morten Mattingsdal,Robert W. McCarley,Colm McDonald,Andrew M. McIntosh,Sandra Meier,Carin J. Meijer,Bela Melegh,Ingrid Melle,Raquelle I. Mesholam-Gately,Andres Metspalu,Patricia T. Michie,Lili Milani,Vihra Milanova,Younes Mokrab,Derek W. Morris,Ole Mors,Kieran C. Murphy,Robin M. Murray,Inez Myin-Germeys,Bertram Müller-Myhsok,Mari Nelis,Igor Nenadic,Deborah A. Nertney,Gerald Nestadt,Kristin K. Nicodemus,Liene Nikitina-Zake,Laura Nisenbaum,Annelie Nordin,Eadbhard O’Callaghan,Colm O’Dushlaine,F. Anthony O’Neill,Sang-Yun Oh,Ann Olincy,Line Olsen,Jim Van Os,Christos Pantelis,George N. Papadimitriou,Sergi Papiol,Elena Parkhomenko,Michele T. Pato,Tiina Paunio,Milica Pejovic-Milovancevic,Diana O. Perkins,Olli Pietiläinen,Jonathan Pimm,Andrew J. Pocklington,John Powell,Alkes Price,Ann E. Pulver,Shaun M. Purcell,Digby Quested,Henrik B. Rasmussen,Abraham Reichenberg,Mark A. Reimers,Alexander L. Richards,Joshua L. Roffman,Panos Roussos,Douglas M. Ruderfer,Veikko Salomaa,Alan R. Sanders,Ulrich Schall,Christian R. Schubert,Thomas G. Schulze,Sibylle G. Schwab,Edward M. Scolnick,Rodney J. Scott,Larry J. Seidman,Jianxin Shi,Engilbert Sigurdsson,Teimuraz Silagadze,Jeremy M. Silverman,Kang Sim,Petr Slominsky,Jordan W. Smoller,Hon-Cheong So,Chris C.A. Spencer,Eli A. Stahl,Hreinn Stefansson,Stacy Steinberg,Elisabeth Stogmann,Richard E. Straub,Eric Strengman,Jana Strohmaier,T. Scott Stroup,Mythily Subramaniam,Jaana Suvisaari,Dragan M. Svrakic,Jin P. Szatkiewicz,Erik Söderman,Srinivas Thirumalai,Draga Toncheva,Sarah Tosato,Juha Veijola,John Waddington,Dermot Walsh,Dai Wang,Qiang Wang,Bradley T. Webb,Mark Weiser,Dieter B. Wildenauer,Nigel M. Williams,Stephanie Williams,Stephanie H. Witt,Aaron R. Wolen,Emily H.M. Wong,Brandon K. Wormley,Hualin Simon Xi,Clement C. Zai,Xuebin Zheng,Fritz Zimprich,Naomi R. Wray,Kari Stefansson,Peter M. Visscher,Psychosis Endophenotypes International Consortium,Rolf Adolfsson,Ole A. Andreassen,Douglas H.R. Blackwood,Elvira Bramon,Joseph D. Buxbaum,Anders D. Børglum,Sven Cichon,Ariel Darvasi,Enrico Domenici,Hannelore Ehrenreich,Tõnu Esko,Pablo V. Gejman,Michael Gill,Hugh Gurling,Christina M. Hultman,Nakao Iwata,Assen V. Jablensky,Erik G. Jönsson,Kenneth S. Kendler,George Kirov,Jo Knight,Todd Lencz,Douglas F. Levinson,Qingqin S. Li,Jianjun Liu,Anil K. Malhotra,Steven A. McCarroll,Andrew McQuillin,Jennifer L. Moran,Preben B. Mortensen,Bryan J. Mowry,Markus M. Nöthen,Roel A. Ophoff,Michael J. Owen,Aarno Palotie,Carlos N. Pato,Tracey L. Petryshen,Danielle Posthuma,Marcella Rietschel,Brien P. Riley,Dan Rujescu,Pak C. Sham,Pamela Sklar,David St Clair,Daniel R. Weinberger,Jens R. Wendland,Thomas Werge,Mark J. Daly,Patrick F. Sullivan,Michael C. O’Donovan,Naomi R. Wray,Stephan Ripke,Manuel Mattheisen,Maciej Trzaskowski,Enda M. Byrne,Abdel Abdellaoui,Mark J. Adams,Esben Agerbo,Tracy M. Air,Till F.M. Andlauer,Silviu-Alin Bacanu,Marie Bækvad-Hansen,Aartjan T.F. Beekman,Tim B. Bigdeli,Elisabeth B. Binder,Julien Bryois,Henriette N. Buttenschøn,Jonas Bybjerg-Grauholm,Na Cai,Enrique Castelao,Jane Hvarregaard Christensen,Toni-Kim Clarke,Jonathan R.I. Coleman,Lucía Colodro-Conde,Baptiste Couvy-Duchesne,Nick Craddock,Gregory E. Crawford,Gail Davies,Ian J. Deary,Franziska Degenhardt,Eske M. Derks,Nese Direk,Conor V. Dolan,Erin C. Dunn,Thalia C. Eley,Valentina Escott-Price,Farnush Farhadi Hassan Kiadeh,Hilary K. Finucane,Jerome C. Foo,Andreas J. Forstner,Josef Frank,Héléna A. Gaspar,Michael Gill,Fernando S. Goes,Scott D. Gordon,Jakob Grove,Lynsey S. Hall,Christine Søholm Hansen,Thomas F. Hansen,Stefan Herms,Ian B. Hickie,Per Hoffmann,Georg Homuth,Carsten Horn,Jouke-Jan Hottenga,David M. Hougaard,David M. Howard,Marcus Ising,Rick Jansen,Ian Jones,Lisa A. Jones,Eric Jorgenson,James A. Knowles,Isaac S. Kohane,Julia Kraft,Warren W. Kretzschmar,Zoltán Kutalik,Yihan Li,Penelope A. Lind,Donald J. MacIntyre,Dean F. MacKinnon,Robert M. Maier,Wolfgang Maier,Jonathan Marchini,Hamdi Mbarek,Patrick McGrath,Peter McGuffin,Sarah E. Medland,Divya Mehta,Christel M. Middeldorp,Evelin Mihailov,Yuri Milaneschi,Lili Milani,Francis M. Mondimore,Grant W. Montgomery,Sara Mostafavi,Niamh Mullins,Matthias Nauck,Bernard Ng,Michel G. Nivard,Dale R. Nyholt,Paul F. O’Reilly,Hogni Oskarsson,Michael J. Owen,Jodie N. Painter,Carsten Bøcker Pedersen,Marianne Giørtz Pedersen,Roseann E. Peterson,Wouter J. Peyrot,Giorgio Pistis,Danielle Posthuma,Jorge A. Quiroz,Per Qvist,John P. Rice,Brien P. Riley,Margarita Rivera,Saira Saeed Mirza,Robert Schoevers,Eva C. Schulte,Ling Shen,Jianxin Shi,Stanley I. Shyn,Engilbert Sigurdsson,Grant C.B. Sinnamon,Johannes H. Smit,Daniel J. Smith,Hreinn Stefansson,Stacy Steinberg,Fabian Streit,Jana Strohmaier,Katherine E. Tansey,Henning Teismann,Alexander Teumer,Wesley Thompson,Pippa A. Thomson,Thorgeir E. Thorgeirsson,Matthew Traylor,Jens Treutlein,Vassily Trubetskoy,André G. Uitterlinden,Daniel Umbricht,Sandra Van der Auwera,Albert M. van Hemert,Alexander Viktorin,Peter M. Visscher,Yunpeng Wang,Bradley T. Webb,Shantel Marie Weinsheimer,Jürgen Wellmann,Gonneke Willemsen,Stephanie H. Witt,Yang Wu,Hualin S. Xi,Jian Yang,Futao Zhang,Volker Arolt,Bernhard T. Baune,Klaus Berger,Dorret I. Boomsma,Sven Cichon,Udo Dannlowski,E.J.C. de Geus,J. Raymond DePaulo,Enrico Domenici,Katharina Domschke,Tõnu Esko,Hans J. Grabe,Steven P. Hamilton,Caroline Hayward,Andrew C. Heath,Kenneth S. Kendler,Stefan Kloiber,Glyn Lewis,Qingqin S. Li,Susanne Lucae,Pamela A.F. Madden,Patrik K. Magnusson,Nicholas G. Martin,Andrew M. McIntosh,Andres Metspalu,Ole Mors,Preben Bo Mortensen,Bertram Müller-Myhsok,Merete Nordentoft,Markus M. Nöthen,Michael C. O’Donovan,Sara A. Paciga,Nancy L. Pedersen,Wellcome Trust Case-Control Consortium
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsych.2021.04.018
IF: 12.81
2021-11-01
Biological Psychiatry
Abstract:<h3 class="u-h4 u-margin-m-top u-margin-xs-bottom">Background</h3><p>Polygenic scores (PGSs), which assess the genetic risk of individuals for a disease, are calculated as a weighted count of risk alleles identified in genome-wide association studies (GWASs). PGS methods differ in which DNA variants are included and the weights assigned to them; some require an independent tuning sample to help inform these choices. PGSs are evaluated in independent target cohorts with known disease status. Variability between target cohorts is observed in applications to real data sets, which could reflect a number of factors, e.g., phenotype definition or technical factors.</p><h3 class="u-h4 u-margin-m-top u-margin-xs-bottom">Methods</h3><p>The Psychiatric Genomics Consortium working groups for schizophrenia (SCZ) and major depressive disorder (MDD) bring together many independently collected case-control cohorts. We used these resources (31K SCZ cases, 41K controls; 248K MDD cases, 563K controls) in repeated application of leave-one-cohort-out meta-analyses, each used to calculate and evaluate PGS in the left-out (target) cohort. Ten PGS methods (the baseline PC+T method and nine methods that model genetic architecture more formally: SBLUP, LDpred2-Inf, LDpred-funct, LDpred2, Lassosum, PRS-CS, PRS-CS-auto, SBayesR, MegaPRS) are compared.</p><h3 class="u-h4 u-margin-m-top u-margin-xs-bottom">Results</h3><p>Compared to PC+T, the other nine methods give higher prediction statistics, MegaPRS, LDPred2 and SBayesR significantly so, up to 9.2% variance in liability for SCZ across 30 target cohorts, an increase of 44%. For MDD across 26 target cohorts these statistics were 3.5% and 59%, respectively.</p><h3 class="u-h4 u-margin-m-top u-margin-xs-bottom">Conclusions</h3><p>Although the methods that more formally model genetic architecture have similar performance, MegaPRS, LDpred2, and SBayesR rank highest in most comparison and are recommended in applications to psychiatric disorders.</p>
neurosciences,psychiatry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?