Observation of Sizeable Ω Contribution to Χc1(3872)→π+<…

R. Aaij,Ahmed Sameh Wagih Abdelmotteleb,Carlos Abellán Beteta,Fernando Jesus Abudinén,Thomas Ackernley,B. Adeva,M. Adinolfi,Hossein Afsharnia,Christina Agapopoulou,C.A Aidala,Salvatore Aiola,Z. Ajaltouni,S. Akar,K. Carvalho Akiba,J. Albrecht,F. Alessio,Michael Alexander,Alejandro Alfonso Albero,Zakariya Aliouche,P. Alvarez Cartelle,S. Amato,Jake Lewis Amey,Y. Amhis,L. An,Lucio Anderlini,M Andersson,Aleksei Andreianov,M. Andreotti,D Ao,F. Archilli,A. Artamonov,M. Artuso,Kenenbek Arzymatov,E. Aslanides,Michele Atzeni,Benjamin Audurier,S Bachmann,Marie Bachmayer,John Back,Aurélien Bailly-Reyre,Pablo Baladron Rodriguez,V. Balagura,W. Baldini,Juan Baptista Leite,Matteo Barbetti,R. J. Barlow,S. Barsuk,W. Barter,Matteo Bartolini,Fedor Baryshnikov,Jan-Marc Basels,Giovanni Bassi,Baasansuren Batsukh,Alexander Battig,A. Bay,Anja Beck,Maurice Becker,F. Bedeschi,I. Bediaga,Andrew Beiter,Vladislav Belavin,Samuel Belin,Violaine Bellée,K. Belous,Ilia Belov,I. Belyaev,G. Bencivenni,E. Ben-Haim,Аlexander Berezhnoy,R. Bernet,Daniel Berninghoff,Harris Conan Bernstein,Claudia Bertella,Alessandro Bertolin,Christopher Betancourt,Federico Betti,Ia. Bezshyiko,Srishti Bhasin,Jihyun Bhom,Lingzhu Bian,Martin Stefan Bieker,Nicolò Vladi Biesuz,S. Bifani,Pierre Billoir,Alice Biolchini,Matthew Birch,Fionn Caitlin Ros Bishop,Alexander Bitadze,A. Bizzeti,Mikkel Bjørn,M.P Blago,T. Blake,F. Blanc,S. Blusk,Dana Bobulska,Julian Alexander Boelhauve,Óscar Boente García,Thomas Boettcher,Alexey Boldyrev,N. Bondar,S. Borghi,Maxim Borisyak,Martino Borsato,Jozef Tomasz Borsuk,Sonia Amina Bouchiba,T. J. V. Bowcock,Alexandre Boyer,C. Bozzi,M.J Bradley,Svende Braun,Alexandre Brea Rodríguez,J. Brodzicka,Arnau Brossa Gonzalo,Davide Brundu,Annarita Buonaura,Laura Buonincontri,Aodhan Tomas Burke,Christopher Burr,A. Bursche,Anatoly Butkevich,Jordy Sebastiaan Butter,J. Buytaert,Wiktor Byczynski,S. Cadeddu,H. Cai,R. Calabrese,Lukas Calefice,Stefano Calí,Ryan Calladine,M. Calvi,M. Calvo Gomez,Patrícia Camargo Magalhães,P. Campana,Angel Campoverde,Simone Capelli,Lorenzo Capriotti,A. Carbone,G. Carboni,R. Cardinale,A. Cardini,Ina Carli,Paolo Carniti,Leon David Carus,Adrián Casais Vidal,Rowina Caspary,G. Casse,M. Cattaneo,Giovanni Cavallero,V Cavallini,Sara Celani,Jacopo Cerasoli,D. Červenkov,Andrew Chadwick,Matthew George Chapman,M. Charles,Ph. Charpentier,Carlos Alberto Chavez Barajas,Maximilien Chefdeville,C Chen,S. Chen,Aleksei Chernov,Veronika Chobanova,Serhii Cholak,M. Chrząszcz,Alexsei Chubykin,Vladimir Chulikov,Paolo Ciambrone,M.F Cicala,Xabier Cid Vidal,G. Ciezarek,G. Ciullo,P. E. L. Clarke,M. Clemencic,Harry Cliff,J. Closier,John Leslie Cobbledick,V. Coco,Joao a B Coelho,J. Cogan,E. Cogneras,Lucian Cojocariu,P. Collins,Tommaso Colombo,Liliana Congedo,A. Contu,Naomi Cooke,George Coombs,Imanol Corredoira,G. Corti,Cayo Mar Costa Sobral,Benjamin Couturier,Daniel Charles Craik,Jana Crkovská,Melissa Maria Cruz Torres,R. Currie,C.L da Silva,Shakhzod Dadabaev,Lingyun Dai,Elena Dall’Occo,J. Dalseno,Carmelo d'Ambrosio,Anna Danilina,Philippe d'Argent,Julian Davies,A. Davis,O. Francisco,J de Boer,K. De Bruyn,S. De Capua,M. De Cian,U de Freitas Carneiro da Graca,E. De Lucia,J. M. De Miranda,L. De Paula,Marilisa de Serio,Dario de Simone,P. De Simone,Fabio de Vellis,Jacco de Vries,C.T Dean,Francesco Debernardis,D. Décamp,Vlad-George Dedu,L. Del Buono,Blaise Delaney,Hans Peter Dembinski,Vadym Denysenko,O. Deschamps,F. Dettori,B. Dey,Alessandro Di Cicco,P. Di Nezza,Sergey Didenko,Lorena Dieste Maroñas,H. Dijkstra,Vasyl Dobishuk,C. Dong,Amanda May Donohoe,F. Dordei,A. C. dos Reis,Lauren Douglas,A.G Downes,Maciej Wojciech Dudek,Laurent Dufour,Viacheslav Duk,Paolo Durante,J.M Durham,Deepanwita Dutta,A. Dziurda,A. Dzyuba,S. Easo,U. Egede,V. Egorychev,S. Eidelman,S. Eisenhardt,Surapat Ek-In,L. Eklund,Scott Ely,Alexandru Ene,Eliane Epple,Stephan Escher,Jonas Nathanael Eschle,Sevda Esen,Hal Evans,L.N Falcao,Yanting Fan,Bo Fang,S. Farry,Davide Fazzini,Mauricio Féo,Antonio Fernández Prieto,C. Fernández-Ramírez,Alex Daniel Fernez,Fabio Ferrari,Lino Ferreira Lopes,F. Ferreira Rodrigues,Silvia Ferreres Sole,Martina Ferrillo,Massimiliano Ferro-Luzzi,Sergey Filippov,Rosa Anna Fini,Massimiliano Fiorini,Mirosław Firlej,Karen M. Fischer,Dillon Scott Fitzgerald,C. Fitzpatrick,Tomasz Fiutowski,F. Fleuret,Marianna Fontana,F. Fontanelli,Roger Forty,Daniel Foulds-Holt,Vinicius Franco Lima,Manuel Franco Sevilla,M. Frank,Edoardo Franzoso,Giulia Frau,C. Frei,David Anthony Friday,J. Fu,Quentin Fuehring,Emmy Gabriel,Giuliana Galati,A. Gallas Torreira,D. Galli,Silvia Gambetta,Yuyue Gan,M. Gandelman,P. Gandini,Y. Gao,Michela Garau,L.M Garcia Martin,Paula García Moreno,Julián García Pardiñas,Beatriz García Plana,Felipe Andrés García Rosales,L. Garrido,C. Gaspar,Robbert Erik Geertsema,David Gerick,Louis Lenard Gerken,E. Gersabeck,M. Gersabeck,T. Gershon,Dawid Gerstel,Luca Giambastiani,V. Gibson,Henryk Karol Giemza,A. Gilman,Matteo Giovannetti,Alessandra Gioventù,Pere Gironella Gironell,Carmen Giugliano,Konstantin Gizdov,Evangelos Leonidas Gkougkousis,V. V. Gligorov,C. Göbel,E Golobardes,D. Golubkov,A. Golutvin,A. Gomes,S. Gomez Fernandez,Fernanda Gonçalves Abrantes,Mateusz Goncerz,Guanghua Gong,I. Gorelov,C. Gotti,Jacek Grabowski,Thomas Grammatico,L. A. Granado Cardoso,E. Graugès,Elena Graverini,G. Graziani,A. Grecu,Lex Marinus Greeven,Nathan Allen Grieser,Lucia Grillo,Sergey Gromov,Barak Raimond Gruberg Cazon,Chenxi Gu,Marco Guarise,Manuel Guittière,Paul Andre Günther,E. Gushchin,Andreas Güth,Yu. Guz,T. Gys,Thomas Hadavizadeh,G. Haefeli,C. Haen,Jakob Haimberger,Susan Haines,Tabitha Halewood-Leagas,M.M Halvorsen,Phoebe Meredith Hamilton,Jan Hammerich,Qundong Han,X. Han,E.B Hansen,S. Hansmann-Menzemer,Hao Long,N. Harnew,Thomas Harrison,Christoph Hasse,Mark Hatch,Jibo He,Malte Hecker,Kevin Heijhoff,Kevin Heinicke,Robert Henderson,Arthur Marius Hennequin,K. Hennessy,Louis Henry,Johannes Heuel,A. Hicheur,D. Hill,Martha Hilton,Sophie Elizabeth Hollitt,Ruiwe Hou,Y Hou,Jifeng Hu,W. Hu,Xiaofan Hu,Wenqian Huang,Xiaozhong Huang,W. Hulsbergen,Ross J. Hunter,Mikhail Hushchyn,D. E. Hutchcroft,D. Hynds,Philipp Ibis,M. Idzik,Dmitrii Ilin,P. Ilten,Alexander Inglessi,Artur Ishteev,Kuzma Ivshin,R. Jacobsson,Hendrik Jage,Sune Jakobsen,E. Jans,Brij Kishor Jashal,A. Jawahery,Vukan Jevtic,Xiaojie Jiang,Malcolm John,D. R. Johnson,Christopher Jones,Thomas Peter Jones,B. Jost,Nathan Jurik,S. Kandybei,Y Kang,M. Karacson,D. Karpenkov,Maksim Karpov,Jacob William Kautz,Floris Keizer,D. Keller,Matthew Kenzie,T. Ketel,B. Khanji,Anastasiia Kharisova,Sergei Kholodenko,Thomas Kirn,Veronica Soelund Kirsebom,Ouail Kitouni,Suzanne Klaver,Nico Kleijne,Konrad Klimaszewski,Mateusz Rafal Kmiec,Serhii Koliiev,Almagul Kondybayeva,Anatoly Konoplyannikov,Paweł Kopciewicz,Renata Kopečná,P. Koppenburg,M. Korolev,Igor Kostiuk,Oleksander Kot,Sofia Kotriakhova,A. Kozachuk,Polina Kravchenko,L. Kravchuk,R.D Krawczyk,M. Kreps,Sophie Katharina Kretzschmar,P. Krokovny,Wojciech Krupa,Wojciech Krzemień,Jakub Kubat,Wojciech Kucewicz,M. Kucharczyk,V. Kudryavtsev,Hilbrand Steffen Kuindersma,G. J. Kunde,T. Kvaratskheliya,D. Lacarrère,G. D. Lafferty,A. Lai,Andrea Lampis,Davide Lancierini,John Jake Lane,Richard Lane,G. Lanfranchi,C. Langenbruch,J Langer,Oliver Lantwin,T. E. Latham,Federico Lazzari,Massimo Lazzaroni,R. Le Gac,S.H Lee,R. Lefèvre,A. Leflat,Sergey Legotin,P. Lenisa,O. Leroy,T. Lesiak,Blake Leverington,H. Li,Peilian Li,S Li,Yiming Li,Z Li,Xixin Liang,Tai-Hua Lin,R. Lindner,Vitalii Lisovskyi,Roman Litvinov,G Liu,H Liu,Qian Liu,S Liu,Aniol Lobo Salvia,Angelo Loi,Riccardo Lollini,Julian Lomba Castro,I. Longstaff,J. H. Lopes,Saúl López Soliño,George Holger Lovell,Y. Lu,Chiara Lucarelli,D. Lucchesi,Stanislav Luchuk,M. Lucio Martínez,Valeriia Lukashenko,Yiheng Luo,Anna Lupato,E. Luppi,Oliver Lupton,A. Lusiani,Xiao-Rui Lyu,L.L. Ma,Ruiting Ma,Serena Maccolini,F. Machefert,F. Maciuc,Vladimír Macko,Patrick Mackowiak,S. Maddrell-Mander,Lakshan Ram Madhan Mohan,Artem Maevskiy,Dmitrii Maisuzenko,Maciej Witold Majewski,Jakub Jacek Malczewski,S. Malde,Bartosz Malecki,А. Малинин,Timofei Maltsev,Hanna Malygina,G. Manca,G. Mancinelli,Daniele Manuzzi,Daniele Marangotto,J. F. Marchand,U. Marconi,Saverio Mariani,Carla Marín Benito,Matthieu Marinangeli,J. Marks,Alexander Mclean Marshall,Phillip John Marshall,Gabriele Martelli,G. Martellotti,Loris Martinazzoli,M. Martinelli,D. Martínez Santos,F. Martínez-Vidal,A. Massafferri,Marcel Materok,R. Matev,Abhijit Mathad,Viacheslav Matiunin,C. Matteuzzi,Kara Renee Mattioli,Andrea Mauri,Émilie Maurice,Juan Mauricio,Michal Kazimierz Mazurek,M. McCann,Lucas Mcconnell,Tamaki Holly Mcgrath,Niall Thomas Mchugh,Andrew Mcnab,R. McNulty,J.V Mead,B. T. Meadows,Gerwin Meier,Dmytro Melnychuk,Simone Meloni,M. Merk,Andrea Merli,Lucas Meyer Garcia,Mikhail Mikhasenko,Diego Alejandro Milanes,Edward James Millard,Marko Milovanovic,Marie-Noelle Minard,Alessandro Minotti,Sara Elizabeth Mitchell,Biljana Mitreska,Dominik Stefan Mitzel,Antje Mödden,R.A Mohammed,Razvan Daniel Moise,Sergei Mokhnenko,Titus Mombächer,Igancio Alberto Monroy,S. Monteil,M. Morandin,G. Morello,M. J. Morello,Jakub Moroń,A.B Morris,Alan Morris,R. Mountain,Hongjie Mu,F. Muheim,Mick Mulder,K. Müller,Colm Harold Murphy,Dónal Murray,Rebecca Murta,Piera Muzzetto,P. Naik,T. Nakada,R. Nandakumar,T. Nanut,I. Nasteva,M. Needham,N. Neri,Sebastian Neubert,Niko Neufeld,P. Neustroev,Ryan Newcombe,E.M Niel,Simon Nieswand,N. Nikitin,Niklas Stefan Nolte,Camille Normand,Cynthia Nunez,A. Obłąkowska-Mucha,V. Obraztsov,Thomas Oeser,Daniel Patrick O'Hanlon,Shinichi Okamura,R. Oldeman,Federica Oliva,Mario Edgardo Olivares,C. J. G. Onderwater,Ryunosuke Hugo O'Neil,J. M. Otalora Goicochea,Tatiana Ovsiannikova,P. Owen,A. Oyanguren,Özlem Özçelik,Klaas Padeken,Bhagyashree Pagare,Preema Rennee Pais,Tommaso Pajero,A. Palano,M. Palutan,Y. Pan,Gennady Panshin,Antonios Papanestis,M. Pappagallo,Luciano Pappalardo,Cheryl Pappenheimer,William Parker,C. Parkes,Barbara Passalacqua,G. Passaleva,Alessandra Pastore,M. Patel,C. Patrignani,C.J Pawley,Alex Pearce,A. Pellegrino,Monica Pepe Altarelli,S. Perazzini,Dmitrii Pereima,Asier Pereiro Castro,P. Perret,M. Petrič,K. Petridis,A. Petrolini,Aleksandr Petrov,Stefano Petrucci,Marco Petruzzo,Hang Pham,Anton Philippov,Roberto Piandani,Lorenzo Pica,Mauro Piccini,B. Pietrzyk,Guillaume Pietrzyk,Martina Pili,A. Pilloni,D. Pinci,Flavio Pisani,Marco Pizzichemi,Vlad-Mihai Placinta,Jonathan Plews,M. Pló Casasús,F. Polci,Marco Poli Lener,Mariia Poliakova,A. Poluektov,Natalia Polukhina,Ivan Polyakov,E. Polycarpo,Sébastien Ponce,D. Popov,Serguei Popov,Stanislav Poslavskii,Kodassery Prasanth,Laura Promberger,Claire Prouvé,V. Pugatch,Véronique Puill,G. Punzi,H. R. Qi,W. Qian,N. Qin,Renato Quagliani,Naomi Veronika Raab,Raul Iraq Rabadan Trejo,Bartłomiej Rachwał,Jonas Rademacker,R. Rajagopalan,M. Rama,Miguel Ramos Pernas,M. S. Rangel,Fedor Ratnikov,G. Raven,Méril Reboud,Federico Redi,Florian Reiss,Clara Remon Alepuz,Zan Ren,Victor Renaudin,P.K Resmi,Roberto Ribatti,A.M Ricci,S. Ricciardi,K. Rinnert,P. Robbe,Gary Robertson,Ana Barbara Rodrigues,Eduardo Rodrigues,Jairo Alexis Rodriguez Lopez,Rodriguez,Alexandra Paige Rollings,Philipp Roloff,Vladimir Romanovskiy,Marcos Romero Lamas,A. Romero Vidal,Jordan Daniel Roth,M. Rotondo,Matthew Scott Rudolph,T. Ruf,Ramón Angel Ruiz Fernández,Joan Ruiz Vidal,Artem Ryzhikov,Jakub Ryzka,J.J Saborido Silva,N. Sagidova,Niladribihari Sahoo,B. Saitta,Matteo Salomoni,Cristina Sanchez Gras,R. Santacesaria,C. Santamarina Ríos,Marco Santimaria,E. Santovetti,Danila Saranin,Gediminas Sarpis,Minaugas Sarpis,A. Sarti,C. Satriano,A. Satta,Miroslav Saur,Darya Savrina,Halime Sazak,Luke George Scantlebury Smead,Alessandro Scarabotto,S. Schael,S Scherl,M. Schiller,H. Schindler,M. Schmelling,B. Schmidt,Sebastian Schmitt,O. Schneider,A. Schopper,Maxime Schubiger,Sebastian Schulte,M. H. Schune,R. Schwemmer,B. Sciascia,A Sciuccati,Sara Sellam,A. Semennikov,Mara Senghi Soares,Antonino Sergi,N. Serra,Lorenzo Sestini,Alex Seuthe,Yiduo Shang,Desmond Mzamo Shangase,M. Shapkin,Ivan Shchemerov,Lesya Shchutska,T. Shears,L. Shekhtman,Zhihong Shen,Shuqi Sheng,V. Shevchenko,Edward Brendan Shields,Yuya Shimizu,Evgenii Shmanin,Joseph David Shupperd,Benedetto Gianluca Siddi,Rafael Silva Coutinho,G. Simi,Saverio Simone,Nicola Skidmore,Raphael Skuza,T. Skwarnicki,M.W. Slater,Igor Slazyk,Jennifer Clare Smallwood,John Gordon Smeaton,E. Smith,M. Smith,Aleksandra Snoch,Lais Soares Lavra,M. D. Sokoloff,Paul Soler,A. Solomin,Ivan Solovyev,Felipe Luan Souza de Almeida,B. Souza De Paula,B. Spaan,Elisabetta Spadaro Norella,E Spiridenkov,P. Spradlin,F. Stagni,Marian Stahl,S. Stahl,Seophine Stanislaus,O. Steinkamp,Oleg Stenyakin,Holger Stevens,S. Stone,Daria Strekalina,Fidan Suljik,J. Sun,L. Sun,Y. Z. Sun,Peter Švihra,Paul Nathaniel Swallow,Krzysztof Świentek,Adam Szabelski,Adam P. Szczepaniak,T. Szumlak,Maciej Paweł Szymański,Shantam Taneja,Alastair Roger Tanner,Martin Duy Tat,Aleksandr Terentev,F. Teubert,E. Thomas,Daniel James David Thompson,Kayleigh Anne Thomson,Hanae Tilquin,V. Tisserand,S. T’Jampens,M. Tobin,Luca Tomassetti,Xingyu Tong,Diego Torres Machado,da Yu Tou,Ekaterina Trifonova,Stoyan Miroslavov Trilov,Carina Trippl,Giulia Tuci,Alison Tully,N. Tuning,A. Ukleja,Daniel Joachim Unverzagt,Eduard Ursov,Andrii Usachov,A. Ustyuzhanin,U. Uwer,Alexander Vagner,V. Vagnoni,Andrea Valassi,G. Valenti,Núria Valls Canudas,M. van Beuzekom,Maarten van Dijk,Hubert van Hecke,E. van Herwijnen,Maarten van Veghel,R. Vazquez Gomez,P. Vázquez Regueiro,C. Vázquez Sierra,S. Vecchi,Jaap Velthuis,M. Veltri,Aravindhan Venkateswaran,Michele Veronesi,M. Vesterinen,D. Vieira,Maria Vieites Diaz,Harald Viemann,X. Vilasís-Cardona,Eva Vilella Figueras,Andrea Villa,P. Vincent,F.C Volle,Dorothea Vom Bruch,A. Vorobyev,V. Vorobyev,Nikolai Voropaev,Kimberley Vos,R. Waldi,J. Walsh,C Wang,J Wang,Jike Wang,M Wang,R Wang,Y Wang,Z. Wang,Z Wang,Ziyi Wang,John A. Ward,Nigel Watson,D. Websdale,Constantin Weißer,B.D.C Westhenry,David J. White,M. Whitehead,Aidan Richard Wiederhold,D. Wiedner,G. Wilkinson,Michael Wilkinson,Ifan Williams,Mike Williams,F. F. Wilson,Wojciech Wiślicki,M. Witek,Lukas Witola,G. Wormser,Stephen Wotton,Haotian Wu,K. Wyllie,Zhou Xiang,David Xiao,Y. Xie,A Xu,J. J. Xu,L. Xu,M. Xu,Qingnian Xu,Z. P. Xu,Z. Xu,Dongqing Yang,S. Yang,Y. Yang,Z. Yang,Zhi Yang,Yuezhe Yao,Lauren Emma Yeomans,Hang Yin,J. Yu,Xuhao Yuan,Ettore Zaffaroni,M. Zavertyaev,Miłosz Zdybał,Oleksandr Zenaiev,Ming Zeng,Dongliang Zhang,L. Zhang,S Zhang,Yanxi Zhang,Alina Zharkova,A. Zhelezov,Y. Zheng,Tianwen Zhou,X. Zhou,Y. Zhou,Valeriia Zhovkovska,Xianglei Zhu,Z. A. Zhu,В. Жуков,Quan Zou,S. Zucchelli,Davide Zuliani,Gianluca Zunica
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.108.l011103
2023-01-01
Abstract:Resonant structures in the dipion mass spectrum from $\chi_{c1}(3872)\to\pi^+\pi^- J/\psi$ decays, produced via $B^+\to K^+\chi_{c1}(3872)$ decays, are analyzed using proton-proton collision data collected by the LHCb experiment, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 9 $fb^{-1}$. A sizeable contribution from the isospin conserving $\chi_{c1}(3872)\to\omega J/\psi$ decay is established for the first time, $(21.4\pm2.3\pm2.0)\%$, with a significance of more than $7.1\sigma$. The amplitude of isospin violating decay, $\chi_{c1}(3872)\to\rho^0 J/\psi$, relative to isospin conserving decay, $\chi_{c1}(3872)\to\omega J/\psi$, is properly determined, and it is a factor of six larger than expected for a pure charmonium state.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?