Complementary Technologies in Innovation Ecosystems:Orchestration, Governance, and Evolution
ZHANG Wei,WANG Liyan,GAO Yuchen
2023-01-01
Abstract:With the increasing complexity of technological innovation, innovation ecosystems become more and more prevalent for organizing technological innovation. Different research streams of innovation ecosystems have highlighted certain technologies aside from core technologies are of strategic importance. These complementary technologies are critical for the core technology to function, for value creation of core innovations, and for value capture of the focal firm; they play an important role in the construction, governance, and evolution of innovation ecosystems. However, existing relevant research is still highly fragmented.We review the literature on complementary technologies in innovation ecosystems, synthesize three different understandings of complementary technologies, and discuss their relevance to innovation ecosystems. First, according to the Profiting from Innovation（PFI） framework, complementary technologies are a special type of complementary assets. Influenced by the PFI framework, Jacobides et al（2018） proposed a theory of ecosystems, arguing that nongeneric complementarities between modules lie at the core of ecosystems; thus, technological modularity and standardization are important research themes related to the governance of complementary technologies. Besides, according to the research related to complementary assets and technological change, the evolution of complementary technologies affects the technological change of core technologies and thus the evolution of related innovation ecosystems. Second, according to what we term a relational view of technological complementarity, it is a form of technological relatedness which denotes the complementarity between two different technologies. This strand of research provides insights into the orchestration of complementary technologies in innovation ecosystems and reveals that complementary technologies influence the standard setting of core technologies. Third, the research on complementary innovations in innovation ecosystems discusses the orchestration,governance, and evolution of complementary technologies, highlighting the structural features of ecosystems and the roles played by different types of ecosystem actors.Further, we summarize three key issues related to complementary technologies in innovation ecosystems and propose a theoretical framework, i.e., orchestration, governance, and evolution of complementary technologies, corresponding to the construction, governance, and evolution of innovation ecosystems, respectively. First, the construction of innovation ecosystems is directly affected by the orchestration of complementary technologies, which includes the identification and selection of complementary technologies and the firm boundary decisions related to complementary technologies. Second,the governance of the innovation ecosystem is directly affected by the governance of complementary technologies, which includes not only the governance of technological interdependencies（e.g., technological modularization and standardization） but also the governance of inter-organizational linkages. Third, innovation ecosystems may evolve as complementary technologies evolve; the evolution of complementary technologies is influenced by technological discontinuities of both core and complementary technologies, as well as the agency of different types of ecosystem actors. Finally, as the process of complementary technology evolution unfolds, the relevant actors need to rearrange the complementary technologies,which may even lead to the reconfiguration of the innovation ecosystem.Future research on this topic can focus on the following aspects. First, future research can examine innovation ecosystems from a perspective of complementary technologies and elucidate how complementary technologies affect the construction, governance and evolution of innovation ecosystems. Second, future research can integrate the study of innovation ecosystems with the literature on technological change, technological competition, and industrial development, where complementary technologies can serve as a suitable anchor point. Third, future research should highlight the differences between complementary technologies and other complementary assets, reveal the interactions between them, and their impacts on the innovation ecosystem. Fourth, future research can study the innovation ecosystem, technological competition,and industrial development from the perspective of complementors. Finally, concerned about the "bottleneck" problems faced by Chinese firms contemporarily, we offer practice implications and policy suggestions.