Meta Analysis of Efficacy Following I~(125) Seeds Stent and Ordinary Covered Stent in Patients with Medium Terminal Cancer of Esophagus

Hesheng Luo,Qiang Tong
2011-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the difference of therapeutic effect between I~(125) seeds stent and ordinary covered stent after implantation in patients with medium terminal cancer of esophagus.Methods Computer-based online search of Medline/ PubMed(1980 -2010),CNKI(1990 -2010) and CHINAINFO(2000-2010) were performed to collected related articles. In addition,Cochrane Library was manually searched.Literature was included in accordance with Cochrane systematic review guidline 4.2.2 Meta analysis was performed to evaluate the data.Results A total of 12 articles were in accordance with the criteria,involving 586 cases,including 296 cases undergoing I~(125) seeds stent and 290 cases undergoing ordinary covered stent. Meta analysis of 12 studies showed that incidence of pain after implantation between two groups was no significant difference [edge ratio = 0.97,95%CI(0.57~1.65),P0:05];so was incidence of bleed[edge ratio = 0.70,95%CI(0.40~1.22),P0.05];incidence of restenosis after undergoing I~(125) seeds stent was lower than ordinary covered stent group[edge ratio = 0.22, 95%CI(0.09~0.52),P0.001].Conclusion Undergoing I~(125) seeds stent in patients with medium terminal cancer of esophagus has reduced incidence of restenosis,but no difference was found in major complications such as pain,bleed compare with ordinary covered stent.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?