Entrepreneurial Ecosystem and National-Level Entrepreneurial Growth Aspiration:A Mixed Study based on fsQCA and NCA Approach
CHENG Jianqing,LIU Qiuchen,DU Yunzhou
2023-01-01
Abstract:High entrepreneurship quality such as high entrepreneurial growth aspiration（EGA） can allow firm to gain sustained competitive advantages, promote regional economic prosperity more effectively.Prior research have focused on the "net effect" of individual institutional elements on EGA, but fail to explore the necessary relationship between specific institutional elements,and the sufficient relationship between institution system and the EGA. Based on entrepreneurial ecosystem（EE） framework, by conducting mixed approach of necessary condition analysis（NCA） as well as fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis（fsQCA）, we explore the causal complexity relationship between entrepreneurial ecosystems（combinations of six explanatory attributes such as financial capital, government policy, human capital, market environment, physical infrastructure, social norm） and EGA, our data is collected from49 countries in 2019 global entrepreneurship monitor（GEM） Report. Results suggest as follows:（1） Any single explanatory attribute of EE does not constitute a necessary condition for high EGA, however, high social norm plays a more general role in generating high EGA;（2） There are 3 equifinal configurations of EE which can generate high EGA, namely, the recipe of financial capital and market freedom to exploit entrepreneurial opportunity driven by legitimacy, which is a primary path for high EGA among these 3 ones, the recipe of infrastructure to create entrepreneurial opportunity driven by legitimacy, the recipe of human capital and market freedom to exploit entrepreneurial opportunity driven by legitimacy;（3） There are 2 equifinal configurations of EE for low EGA, which is casual asymmetry compared with the configurations of EE that produce high EGA.The theoretical contributions highlight as follows:（1） Based on entrepreneurial ecosystem theory, we integrate the six explanatory attributes of EE, explore necessary relationship between the single explanatory attributes of EE and high EGA, which is beyond their correlational relationship;（2） Anchored in configuration theorizing, we explore sufficient relationship between EE and high EGA, which enriches prior studies by offering a more fine-grained insights on complex entrepreneurship phenomenon;（3） By conducting the mixed study of NCA and fsQCA, we offer a methodological reference on how to explore the necessary and sufficient causal complexity relationship between the EE and EGA.Our management implication suggests that China needs to increase the publicity on entrepreneurial role models, promote entrepreneurship spirit, and create a culture of tolerance for entrepreneurial failure. Meanwhile, while continuing to improve other elements of the EE, we should base ourselves on China’s actual conditions, actively learn from the EE of Chile and other countries in transition, focus on formulating tax policies to support entrepreneurship, creating a supportive entrepreneurial culture, and improving infrastructure construction, so as to enhance China’s EGA. In addition, in formulating policies to activate high-quality entrepreneurship, China should cultivate dialectical thinking and avoid inefficient EEs, especially those of the Ecuadorian or Korean model.Future research is suggested as follows:（1） The number of cases needs to be expanded. Limited by the availability of data, this study only explores the antecedent mechanism of EGA in 49 countries, which weakens the universality of the conclusions, future research can collect relevant data from more countries to improve the generalizability of our conclusions.（2） The fsQCA approach needs to be improved in terms of temporal dynamics of EE. In this study, the relationship between the national EE and EGA is only statically discussed, ignoring the dynamic self-sustaining characteristics of the EE, future research can conduct temporal QCA to deeply explore the dynamic relationship between the evolution of EE and EGA to improve the robustness of our conclusions.（3） Whether the conclusions of this study can be directly generalized to different regional levels in China needs to be verified. Based on the perspective of EE, this study explores the heterogeneous antecedents of EGA among different countries, but does not fully explore the heterogeneous causes of EGA at the provincial, urban or county level in China, future research can empirically test the relationship between the EE and EGA at these different regional levels in China to deepen our conclusions.