Abstract:This study investigated the effects of the single programming approach (plugged-in and unplugged) and the mixed programming approach (plugged-in-first and unplugged-first) on the computational thinking (CT) skills of first-grade students. However, focusing only on the programming learning approach itself is insufficient. Therefore, the influences of students’ gender, programming experience, programming interest, and programming confidence factors on CT skills were also examined. 121 students from China were divided into four experimental and one control groups and engaged in the programming activities intervention for 10 weeks. The data consisted mainly of students’ CT skill scores before and after the programming activities intervention. The results showed that both single and mixed programming approaches significantly improved students’ CT skills, with the mixed programming approaches being more effective. Furthermore, the study found that the implementation of unplugged activities in the first stage attenuated the effects of programming experience. Furthermore, it was found that the unplugged-first programming approach was able to diminish the effect of students’ programming experience on the development of CT skills and could be an essential condition to promote the development of equal CT skills. We also clarified the important role of programming interest and programming confidence in students’ CT development. More importantly, a chain mediation effect of programming experience and programming interest between programming confidence and CT was also found. Finally, this study further discusses ideas and approaches for the future of CT education for primary school students and provides certain practical suggestions and insights for teachers and researchers.

Different Programming Approaches on Primary Students’ Computational Thinking: a Multifactorial Chain Mediation Effect

Single or Combined? A Study on Programming to Promote Junior High School Students’ Computational Thinking Skills

Three Contrasting Pairs’ Collaborative Programming Processes in China’s Secondary Education

Effects of Cognitive Control Strategies on Coding Learning Outcomes in Early Childhood

The Role Gender Differences In Computational Thinking Confidence Levels Plays In Stem Applications

Effect of Unplugged Programming Teaching Aids on Children’s Computational Thinking and Classroom Interaction: with Respect to Piaget’s Four Stages Theory

Developing and Testing a Design-Based Learning Approach to Enhance Elementary Students’ Self-Perceived Computational Thinking

Comparing the effects of plugged-in and unplugged activities on computational thinking development in young children

Engagement predicts computational thinking skills in unplugged activity: Analysis of gender differences

Exploring the characteristics of an optimal design of non-programming plugged learning for developing primary school students’ computational thinking in mathematics

Computational thinking through unplugged activities in early years of Primary Education

Teaching programming and computational thinking in early childhood education: a case study of content knowledge and pedagogical knowledge

Designing Unplugged and Plugged Activities to Cultivate Computational Thinking: An Exploratory Study in Early Childhood Education

Exploring children’s perceptions of developing twenty-first century skills through computational thinking and programming

Learning Performance of Different Genders’ Computational Thinking

Transitioning from Introductory to Professional Programming in Secondary Education: Comparing Learners’ Computational Thinking Skills, Behaviors, and Attitudes

Computational thinking in early childhood is underpinned by sequencing ability and self-regulation: a cross-sectional study

From Critique to Computational Thinking: A Peer-Assessment-Supported Problem Identification, Flow Definition, Coding, and Testing Approach for Computer Programming Instruction

Block-based Versus Text-Based Programming: a Comparison of Learners’ Programming Behaviors, Computational Thinking Skills and Attitudes Toward Programming

Unplugged versus plugged-in: examining basic programming achievement and computational thinking of 6th-grade students

An exploratory approach for investigating the integration of computational thinking and mathematics for preschool children