Egg Covering by Cavity-Nesting Birds: an Experimental Test of the Usurpation Hypothesis

Jinmei Liu,Fangfang Zhang,Xuan Zhang,Wei Liang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-023-03377-9
2023-01-01
Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology
Abstract:Some secondary cavity-nesting birds use nest material to cover their eggs when they are out foraging during the egg-laying stage. Egg covering presumably helps regulate nest temperature and/or prevents predation or parasitism. A recent study suggested that egg covering might prevent nest usurpation and therefore, we set up nest boxes with three different treatments to test this hypothesis: bottom of the nest box covered with moss containing two eggs covered with moss (type A); floor of the nest box covered with moss and two eggs exposed on top of the moss (Type B); and bare floor of the nest box, with two eggs added (Type C). The results showed the lowest egg predation rates in Type A nest boxes, which was significantly lower than those in type C boxes; the proportion of maritime striped squirrels (Tamiops maritimus), first appearing in the three types of nest box was not significantly different; however, the rate of first entry into Type A was significantly lower than that into Type C boxes. The rate of first entry and the time the squirrels spent in Type A boxes were significantly lower and shorter than those in Type C boxes. Our results suggest that the egg-covering behavior of secondary cavity-nesting birds delayed the entry of nest competitors and accelerated the departure of nest encroachers from the nest, thus provided experimental evidence for the usurpation hypothesis. Several non-mutually exclusive hypotheses have been proposed to explain the function of egg covering by bird species. The present study showed that egg covering by secondary cavity-nesting birds delayed the entry of maritime striped squirrels and accelerated the departure of nest encroachers from the nest, suggesting that egg covering might reduce the cost of nest defense for birds and thus prevent nest encroachment by other species. We provided experimental evidence for the new hypothesis proposed by Slagsvold and Wiebe (2021a) that egg-covering behavior of birds deters nest encroachers from easily entering unfamiliar, poorly lit cavities due to fear, thereby effectively preventing nest usurpation by squirrels.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?