Abstract:Background Avian brood parasites and their hosts are involved in complex offence-defense coevolutionary arms races. The most common pair of reciprocal adaptations in these systems is egg discrimination by hosts and egg mimicry by parasites. As mimicry improves, more advanced host adaptations evolve such as decreased intra- and increased interclutch variation in egg appearance to facilitate detection of parasitic eggs. As interclutch variation increases, parasites able to choose hosts matching best their own egg phenotype should be selected, but this requires that parasites know their own egg phenotype and select host nests correspondingly. Methodology/Principal Findings We compared egg mimicry of common cuckoo Cuculus canorus eggs in naturally parasitized marsh warbler Acrocephalus palustris nests and their nearest unparasitized conspecific neighbors having similar laying dates and nest-site characteristics. Modeling of avian vision and image analyses revealed no evidence that cuckoos parasitize nests where their eggs better match the host eggs. Cuckoo eggs were as good mimics, in terms of background and spot color, background luminance, spotting pattern and egg size, of host eggs in the nests actually exploited as those in the neighboring unparasitized nests. Conclusions/Significance We reviewed the evidence for brood parasites selecting better-matching host egg phenotypes from several relevant studies and argue that such selection probably cannot exist in host-parasite systems where host interclutch variation is continuous and overall low or moderate. To date there is also no evidence that parasites prefer certain egg phenotypes in systems where it should be most advantageous, i.e., when both hosts and parasites lay polymorphic eggs. Hence, the existence of an ability to select host nests to maximize mimicry by brood parasites appears unlikely, but this possibility should be further explored in cuckoo-host systems where the host has evolved discrete egg phenotypes.

Common Cuckoo Females Remove More Conspicuous Eggs During Parasitism

Cryptic Eggs Are Rejected Less Frequently by a Cuckoo Host

Oriental reed warblers retain strong egg recognition abilities during the nestling stage

Egg Laying Behavior of Common Cuckoos（cuculus Canorus）: Data Based on Field Video-Recordings

Experimental Evidence That Cuckoos Preferentially Parasitize Host Nests Early in Their Laying Cycle

How Cuckoos Find and Choose Host Nests for Parasitism

Cuckoos Use Host Egg Number to Choose Host Nests for Parasitism.

Are Cuckoos Maximizing Egg Mimicry by Selecting Host Individuals with Better Matching Egg Phenotypes?

Egg Recognition As Antiparasitism Defence in Hosts Does Not Select for Laying of Matching Eggs in Parasitic Cuckoos

Egg mimicry and host selection by common cuckoos among four sympatric host species breeding within a reed habitat

Do Common Cuckoos (cuculus Canorus) Possess an Optimal Laying Behaviour to Match Their Own Egg Phenotype to That of Their Oriental Reed Warbler (acrocephalus Orientalis) Hosts

Why Cuckoos Should Parasitize Parrotbills by Laying Eggs Randomly Rather Than Laying Eggs Matching the Egg Appearance of Parrotbill Hosts

Plaintive Cuckoos Do Not Select Tailorbird Hosts That Match the Phenotypes of Their Own Eggs

Why Cuckoos Remove Host Eggs: Biting Eggs Facilitates Faster Parasitic Egg‐laying

Random Egg Laying in Host Nests, Rather Than Egg-Matching, Explains Patterns of Cuckoo Parasitism: a Comment on Zhang Et Al. (2023).

Egg Rejection Based on Egg Size Recognition As a Specific Strategy Against Parasitic Cuckoos

Brood parasitism and host-parasite relationships: Cuckoos adapt to reduce the time of hatching ahead of host nestlings by increasing egg thickness

Female Cuckoo Calls Deceive Their Hosts by Evoking Nest-Leaving Behavior: Variation under Different Levels of Parasitism

Common cuckoo eggs are more resistant to puncture by the host

Do Cuckoos Imprint on Hosts, Micro-Habitats, or Nest Sites? Parasitism Preferences in the Common Cuckoo ( Cuculus Canorus )

Keeping Eggs Warm: Thermal and Developmental Advantages for Parasitic Cuckoos of Laying Unusually Thick-Shelled Eggs