Comparison of the Models of Using ~7be to Estimate Soil Erosion Rate

Guangqian Wang

2010-01-01

Journal of Soil and Water Conservation

Abstract:7Be,which is a excellent soil erosion tracer,have been employed for documenting short-term or individual-event soil redistribution on cultivated land or bare land in recent decades in many areas of the world.The models which were established by Walling,Yang and Wilson et al.for using 7Be to estimate soil erosion rate were summarized and the comparison of the results of these models were conducted by the measured data which got from the runoff plots under the simulated rainfall.The results showed that the Walling’s,Yang’s and Wilson model have relatively higher precision for only sheet erosion plots when estimated the sheet erosion rates.However,the relative error for Wilson model was more than others.For the rill erosion runoff plots,the absolute differences between the values estimated by the Walling’s and the Yang’s models were relatively less.The absolute differences for the only sheet erosion runoff plots were less than for the rill erosion runoff plots.The total erosion amount estimated by Wilson’s model was comparatively accurate.Compared with the measured data,the relative error ranged from 3.59% to 14.47%.The relative error for the only sheet erosion runoff plots was more than for the rill erosion runoff plots.The precision of these models was decreasing with the increasing of the soil erosion intensity for the rill erosion runoff plots.