Abstract:Many principles controlling the modern western civil law, such as consideration, prescription and capacity, have taken shape in history. This paper, from a historical perspective, explores the logic and rationale behind Chinese common law by focusing on the formation of contract in the Qing Dynasty. The first section shows that in the Qing Dynasty, the delivering of the subject matter was a basic requirement to form a loan contract between two parties. However, an agreement for transferring the item in advance worked as a consensual and bilateral contract, and the aggrieved party could ask for compensation or contractual fine or retain the deposit when the other party broke the contract. The second section argues that in the Qing Dynasty, the writing of a loan contract (Shuqi) is not a contract in and of itself, but is only one of the forms of contracts. The writing worked as the primary evidence of the existence of a contract. In the third section, the requirements of consideration and prescription are used to understand the practice of civil trials in the Qing Dynasty. Back then, when the loan contracts provided by two parties entailed some defects, the judges would adjudicate a loan dispute on the basis of consideration, with an assumption that people acted in their own interest and only in this sense were their acts rational. The judges could also identify the right(s) of parties due to the lapse of time. The fourth section argues against the view that equality was not used as a principle to form civil contracts in Chinese history. In Ancient China, there was indeed inequality between officials and laymen and within family or clan. However, in the Qing Dynasty, the different social status of the parties had little to do with the formation of contract. The restrictions for junior individuals (e.g. beiyou) to dispose his family property were actually restrictions on their capability instead of limitations on his capacity to enjoy private right or to have private obligation.

Reason Beyond Logic: A Comparative Study of Thieves' Surrendering Between Qing Dynasty and the Modern Times

Voluntary Surrender and Confession in Chinese Law: The Problem of Continuity

A legal historical study on surrender system: Investigations from Tang Code to modern criminal law

Reflections upon the Centennial Abolition of the Imperial Examination System

Analysis on Rational Correction of Application Scope of Voluntary Surrender System in China

Discussion on the Cognizance of Go Beyond One's Cognizance Voluntary Surrender in Traffic Accident Crimes

The Vicissitudes of Chinese Criminal Law and Theory

Imported Rules and Traditional Customs in the Process of Legal Modernization:The Case of Sacrificial Fields

Incomplete Circulation——The Historical Development of “System of Criminal Theory” in Modern China

Crime and punishment: Chinese philosophies and perspectives

A Study of the Research Mode on the Traditional Legal Ideology of the Ancient China --citing an Example of "rite and Punishment" from the Confucianism Theory Before the Qin Dynasty

"Follow the Local Rule" --Rural Judges' Strategies for Negotiation between Law and Qingli

Dynastic Transition and Social Transformation: Behavioral Changes of Jiangnan Literati During the Ming Qing Period

On Penalty-ransom System in Ancient China

Unravelling the paradigm shift of imposing capital punishment for property offences in early qing dynasty

New Study on Criminal Law of Qing Dynasty Approved by Emperor

Reinterrogating Prisoners and Natural Calamities: Influence of the Manner of Relieving Natural Disasters on the Judicial System in Ancient China

Human Rights Protection in the Surrender of Fugitive Offenders between Mainland China, Hong Kong and Macau

DISCOVERING THE CHINESE COMMON LAW: THE FORMATION OF THE LOAN CONTRACT IN THE QING DYNASTY

On the Influence of the Ancient Fuyu's Law to the Laws of Ancient East Asia

A Comparative Study of Crime of Embezzlement between Mainland and Taiwan