Vitodynamics turnover after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction of autograft flexor tendon
Feng Yuan,Jin-zhong Zhao,Xiao-qiao Huangfu,Yao-hua He,Jian-hua Wang,Yue Zhu,Xiao-chun Peng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1673-8225.2006.33.043
2006-01-01
Abstract:Aim: To establish anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction of dogs with autograft flexor tendon, and compare the total maximal tensile strength and the rigidity of the graft after reconstruction in different period. Methods: The experiment was conducted in animal experiment center, Shanghai Sixth People's Hospital, Mechanics Research Center, Shanghai Jiao Tong University from January to December 2005. Twenty-one mature beagle dogs were selected and divided into two groups at random. Fifteen beagles served as reconstruction ACL group and six beagles served as normal control group. (1) ACL of the beagles of reconstruction group were reconstructed with autograft flexor tendon and fixed with stainless steel screw. 0.5, 1, 1.5, 3, 6 month after operation, grafts were harvested from three of beagles every time. The specimen included distal femur, proximal tibia and the reconstruction ACL. The other soft tissue between femue and tibia was removed. The maximal tensile strength and the rigidity of the graft then were tested. (2) These in the control group was intact. The specimen included distal femur, proximal tibia and the normal ACL of each knee joint. The other soft tissue between femue and tibia was removed. The specimen was determined with mechanics method. (3) All the specimens were tested through an all-powerful material test machine of German Zwick. A 2 N preload was applied and specimens were then loaded until failure with a 10 mm displacement rate per minute. The maximal tensile strength and rigidity of the specimens were tested and the position that the specimen breaks was recorded. Results: Totally twenty-one mature beagle dogs were used in this study. All of them were involved in the analysis of results. (1) The results of maximal tensile strength and rigidity of the control group: The maximal tensile strength of flexor tendon was (564.15±36.18)N. The rigidity of flexor tendon was (59.89±4.28)N/mm. The mean maximal tensile strength of ACL was (684.75±48.10)N. The rigidity of ACL was (74.34±6.99)N/mm. The entire femur-ACL-tibia complex ruptured point through the intra-articular portion of the graft. At time zero, the total maximal tensile strength of femur-graft-tibia complex was (301.92±15.04)N and the rigidity was(31.35±1.97)N. All the specimens ruptured point through the suture in the bone tunnel. (2) The maximal tensile strength and rigidity of reconstruction ACL group: The maximal tensile strength after month 0.5, 1, 1, 5, 3, 6 exhibited (72.59±6.17)N, (34.26±2.12)N, (73.91±6.88)N, (180.97±6.25)N, (393.93±32.46)N. The rigidity exhibited (13.18±1.23)N/mm, (6.56 ±1.35)N/mm, (13.27 ±2.10)N/mm, (22.46 ±2.29)N/mm, (28.74 ±1.30)N/mm. (3) Comparison of maximal tensile strength and rigidity at different time point between the two groups after reconstruction: The maximal tensile strength of the reconstruction group after month 0.5, 1, 1, 5, 3, 6 exhibited 24.0%, 11.3%, 24.5%, 60.0%, 130.5% of that of the normal control group reconstruction at time zero, respectively. The rigidity of the reconstruction group after month 0.5, 1, 1, 5, 3, 6 exhibited 42.0%, 20.9%, 42.3%, 71.7%, 91.7% of that of the normal control group reconstruction at time zero, respectively. Conclusion: After ACL reconstruction of dogs with autograft flexor tendon, the maximal tensile strength and rigidity of the graft die down at first and strengthen gradually again with the prolongation of time, which will provide experimental basis for designing rehabilitative plan of reconstruction in clinic.