Bond Price Fragility and the Structure of the Mutual Fund Industry

Mariassunta Giannetti,Chotibhak Jotikasthira

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/rfs/hhad095

IF: 8.4137

2024-03-25

Review of Financial Studies

Abstract:We conjecture that mutual funds with large shares of outstanding bond issues are more inclined to internalize the negative price spillovers of fire sales and thus sell their holdings in those issues, to a lower extent, when they experience redemptions. We provide evidence consistent with this conjecture and further show that ownership concentration limits bonds' exposures to flow-induced fire sales. We exploit variation in negative spillovers arising from the Fed's SMCCF to confirm the economic mechanism and explore our findings' implications for fund performance and fire-sale spillovers to other funds.

economics,business, finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores how bond mutual funds strategically adjust their portfolios under redemption pressure to mitigate the negative impact of "fire sales" and analyzes the potential implications of this behavior on financial stability.

### Issues the Paper Attempts to Address:

1. **Strategic Behavior and Price Spillover Effects**: When bond mutual funds face large-scale redemptions, do they selectively reduce the sale of bonds in which they hold large shares to internalize the negative price spillover effects?

2. **Role of Ownership Concentration**: How does ownership concentration affect the sensitivity of bonds to fire sales triggered by fund flows?

3. **Economic Consequences of Strategic Behavior**: What are the economic consequences of bond mutual funds' strategic behavior on their own performance and the secondary impact of fire sales on other funds?

### Key Findings:

- When bond mutual funds face large-scale redemptions, they tend to sell less of the bonds in which they hold larger shares. This behavior helps limit the price decline caused by fire sales.

- The concentration of bond ownership can reduce the sensitivity of bonds to fire sales triggered by fund outflows. Specifically, if a bond is highly held by a few large funds, its price remains relatively more stable during fire sales.

- Funds that strategically reduce the proportion of specific bond sales tend to perform better and help mitigate the secondary impact of fire sales on other funds.

### Empirical Evidence:

- The authors provide empirical evidence supporting the above hypotheses and use the changes in negative spillover effects caused by the Federal Reserve's Secondary Market Corporate Credit Facility (SMCCF) to confirm the effectiveness of the economic mechanism.

- The study also shows that funds with a high proportion of large bond holdings (i.e., HIGHLARGEFRAC funds) perform better during turbulent periods, with a lower correlation between fund outflows and negative performance. This further enhances asset stability and limits the impact of secondary redemptions.

### Conclusion:

In summary, the paper reveals through empirical research how bond mutual funds strategically manage their portfolios to cope with redemption pressure and demonstrates how this behavior can enhance the overall stability of the financial system.