Income Inequality and Housing Affordability in Beijing - an Empirical Study from Household Survey

Zan Yang,Songtao Wang

2007-01-01

Abstract:Income Inequality and Housing Affordability in Beijing - An Empirical Study from Household Survey

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The Impact of Privatization of Public Housing on Housing Affordability in Beijing: an Assessment Using Household Survey Data

Zan Yang,Songtao Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0269094211409140

2011-01-01

Local Economy The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit

Abstract:Housing affordability has long been on the agenda of China’s policy makers. Imperfections in the housing system and growing disparities in income and wealth have been central to the problem of affordable housing. Housing reforms in China led to the creation of a market-oriented housing system, but also increased economic and social stratification. This article considers the effect of privatization of public housing on the problem of housing affordability in Beijing. We draw on a household survey to assess affordability for households according to occupants’ family structures, educational attainments and employment status, using a ‘residual income’ approach. The implications for policies designed to improve housing affordability are discussed.
Decomposition Analysis on Income Inequality in Urban China

Qu Jing,Yao Xianguo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-4565.2011.11.008

2011-01-01

Abstract:The paper investigates income inequality in urban China by using 2002—2007 UHS datasets.It finds that:(1) The Gini coefficient rose first and then fell,and it's 0.342,0.361 and 0.349 for 2002,2004 and 2007 separately.(2) The effects of real estate market and finance market on enlarging income inequality are increasingly stronger.Income from wealth has become the third important factor affecting income inequality,whose effects are just inferior to those of wage income and net public transfer income,and its contribution rate has arrived at 7.3% in 2007.(3) Real estate investments can enlarge income inequality more greatly than finance investments because of the higher investment threshold and the lasting rise of house prices.
The Affordability of Owner Occupied Housing in Beijing

Zan Yang,Yue Shen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10901-008-9120-2

2008-01-01

Journal of Housing and the Built Environment

Abstract:Facilitating home ownership and providing more affordable housing has received considerable attention in urban China. However, it remains a challenge to develop better measurements of affordability due to the income disparity and housing inequality in Beijing. In this study, a new measure of affordability is defined by residual income. Therefore, a minimum required budget for a family to purchase a “standard” unit is deduced by accounting for the basic necessities and financial loans. This paper also discusses the deficiencies of the implemented “Economic Housing Plan” on bridging the housing affordability gap.
Housing Inequality in Urban China

Qiang Ren,Rongqin Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2057150x15624894

2016-01-01

Chinese Journal of Sociology

Abstract:Using data from a nationwide longitudinal survey, the current inequalities in housing conditions, property, ownership rate, market value, and dynamic changes of housing with difficulties were studied, and the affected factors from the characteristics of households and regional variations in urban China were explored. It was found that 77% of urban households owned their own houses, but 14% had housing difficulties in 2012. In addition, it was found that more than 67% of families owned one house, and more than 15% owned two or more. The median market value of current housing was 250,000 yuan, and the median market value per square meter was 2587 yuan. Finally, it was determined that household-level characteristics played important roles in housing inequality, and that regional variations significantly affected the likelihood of housing difficulties being present.
Affordability of Housing and Accessibility of Public Services: Evaluation of Housing Programs in Beijing

Zan Yang,Chengdong Yi,Wei Zhang,Chun Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10901-013-9363-4

2013-01-01

Journal of Housing and the Built Environment

Abstract:Acute housing poverty and low housing affordability among low-to-medium-income households have become challenges in the pursuit of a harmonious society in China. Promoting housing subsidies and stimulating investment on affordable housing have been at the center of China’s housing policy. This paper analyzes the correlation of affordable housing program in Beijing with household affordability of adequate housing and accessibility to public services, which include elementary and middle schools, hospitals and public transportation. Economic and Comfortable Housing is studied based on unique database of eligible household and affordable housing projects. We find that the program fails to make housing affordable and accessible for eligible households. The implications of housing policy design in the context of the economic and social well-being of targeted households are highlighted in the study.
Job-Accessibility-Based Housing Affordability Index: An Application In Beijing

Kejing Liu,Siqi Zheng,Hong Zhang

2010-01-01

Abstract:Both theoretical and empirical researches support the argument that job accessibility should be built into housing affordability evaluation. We use a new information tool, which is called Job-Accessibility-Based Housing Affordability Index, to quantify the impact of commuting cost on the affordability of housing decisions in Beijing. This new index calculates the true affordability of a home based on its market value and the transportation cost incurred by its location. Using the data of zone-level household incomes, housing costs and commuting costs of 64 residential zones in Beijing, we calculate two sets of this new affordability index, for car drivers (high-income group) and other commuters (low-income group), respectively. We also present the spatial variations of the indices for the two population groups and examine the underlying forces. Our empirical findings can help households assess which neighbourhoods are most affordable when considering housing and transportation costs together, and it can also assist policymakers in determining where resources should be focused to enhance affordability.
From Income and Housing Wealth Inequalities to Emissions Inequality: Carbon Emissions of Households in China

Zan Yang,Shuping Wu,Hiu Ying Cheung

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10901-016-9510-9

2016-01-01

Journal of Housing and the Built Environment

Abstract:The emerging notion of emissions inequality expands the idea of sustainability by incorporating economic opportunity as well as social needs and rights into environmental costs and benefits. In China, increasing inequality among urban households in terms of both income and housing wealth establishes a pattern of social stratification. An understanding of the association of social and environmental inequality is thus critical for urban sustainability. Based on the Chinese urban household survey from 2002 to 2009, this article employs the lifestyle approach to calculate and analyse the inequality of households by direct and indirect carbon emissions. The correlations among carbon emission inequality with income and housing wealth inequality are estimated with a Heckman procedure. We find that not only income distribution but also housing wealth distributionis an important consideration in understanding environmental inequality in China.
Affordability Index for Transportation and Housing:An Application in Beijing

Siqi ZHENG,Kejing LIU,Weizeng SUN

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-3862.2011.02.009

2011-01-01

Urban Studies

Abstract:Urban spatial structure theories indicate that urban land use and transportation are closely interacted.Transportation cost and housing cost induced by residential location choice are highly correlated.Therefore,the traditional housing affordability indicators cannot sufficiently reveal the location-specific cost burden for households.This paper designs a new affordability index for transportation and housing,and estimates this index for 64 zones in Beijing.The policy implications of this new index are also discussed.
Housing Affordability and Housing Vacancy in China: the Role of Income Inequality

Chuanchuan Zhang,Shen Jia,Rudai Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhe.2016.05.005

IF: 2.268

2016-01-01

Journal of Housing Economics

Abstract:China's urban housing price has dramatically increased in the past decade, surpassing income growth and raising fears of a real estate bubble. The increase in housing price is also accompanied by a growing number of vacant apartments. This paper argues that income inequality is one important factor driving up both the housing price relative to income and the housing vacancy rate. Using data from China's Urban Household Survey, the paper empirically examines the effects of income inequality on the housing price-to-income ratio and housing vacancy rate within each city. We find that the income GINI coefficient is positively related to the housing price-to-income ratio as well as the housing vacancy rate. In particular, a one percentage higher GINI coefficient is associated with increases in the housing price-to-income ratio and housing vacancy rate of 0.026 points and 0.166 percentage points, respectively. During 2002 and 2009, approximately 6% of the increase in the housing price-to-income ratio and 10% of the increase in the housing vacancy rate can be attributed to the increase of the GINI coefficient. Further studies show that the development of the capital market and housing rental market are somewhat helpful in mitigating the associations between income inequality and the housing price-to-income ratio and vacancy rate. (C) 2016 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Evaluation of Affordability and Accessibility of Public Rental Housing: A Case study of Beijing

YANG Zan,ZHANG Wei,YI Chengdong,GAO Boyang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-3862.2013.10.012

2013-01-01

Abstract:Effective affordable housing supply calls for affordability and accessibility to public services. This paper analyzes the affordability of eligible households of Public Rental Housing programs in Beijing,using the Residual Income Approach. Result shows that the distribution of Public Rental Housing rent subsidies significantly improves the affordability of low-income households and lowto-middle-income households. While income gap still exists among partial low-income households and low-to-middle-income households. Meanwhile,accessibility to public services,including elementary and middle schools,hospitals and public transportation,is measured based on the spatial distribution of Public Rental Housing programs in Beijing. The result indicates that Public Rental Housing projects are generally located between the fifth ring and sixth ring in eastern,northern and southern Beijing,with relatively poor traffic accessibility and imbalanced distribution of education and health resources. The result reveals the challenging of Public Rental Housing in both affordability and accessibility in Beijing.
Examining spatial pattern and location choice of affordable housing in Beijing, China: Developing a workable assessment framework

Mingxing Chen,Wenzhong Zhang,Dadao Lu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0042098014542133

2014-07-17

Urban Studies

Abstract:Little research is devoted to evaluating the spatial patterns of affordable housing in Beijing. For filling this gap by developing a workable assessment framework, this paper addresses the importance of assessing the spatial patterns of affordable housing, not only for the wellbeing of low- and middle-income households but also for urban sustainable development, and presents Beijing as a case study. Using GIS-based spatial analysis, this study assesses the spatiotemporal dynamics of location and affordable housing in Beijing from 1999 to 2012. We posit that spatial agglomeration is gradually decreasing, and the spatial patterns demonstrate an equilibrium distribution in this urban area. The hypotheses were tested using three indexes, Lorenz curves and data on 294 affordable housing projects within the Sixth Ring Roads in Beijing. Our analysis demonstrates that affordability patterns are obviously spatially clustered, and affordable housing is mainly located at the urban fringe. The direct cause is that low- and middle-income households have little impact on determining the location of affordable housing. Therefore, clustering pattern should be reconsidered and improved when constructing future affordable housing projects in Beijing.

environmental studies,urban studies
Housing Inequality in Urban China: Theoretical Debates, Empirical Evidences, and Future Directions

Yiping Fang,Zhilin Liu,Yulin Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0885412219880898

2019-01-01

Journal of Planning Literature

Abstract:Within three decades, the urban housing reform in China has changed access to housing from a system of socialist administrative allocation to that of more market-dominated housing development and consumption. Researchers have studied the socioeconomic and spatial consequences of these profound transformations. This review focuses on China’s housing inequality literature in relation to the changing origins, spatial patterns, and recent policy responses. The article reveals the unique features of China’s transitional economy along with massive urbanization, in which housing inequalities are rooted in socialism and strengthened by institutional changes of a state-led market economy.
Multi-dimensional Housing Inequality Index: The Provincial Evidence from China

Junhua Chen,Shufan Ma,Na Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11205-022-03034-0

2022-11-07

Social Indicators Research

Abstract:Since the reform of the housing system in 1998, China's housing distribution system has changed from welfare- to a market-based distribution, forming a unique phenomenon of housing inequality. Existing research on housing inequality mainly focuses on housing inequality in a single dimension and a single year, in which the importance of housing welfare based on household registration ( hukou ) has been ignored. This study examined China's housing inequality from three dimensions: housing living condition, housing wealth, and housing welfare based on hukou . Based on the data from the four-times China household finance survey and the generalized entropy measurement model, this study investigated the dynamic trends of China's housing inequality and showed that the degree of China's housing inequality has an overall upward trend from 2011 to 2017. Moreover, this research also calculated the provincial housing inequality and conducted the regression analysis to investigate the factors that affect housing inequality in each province. It was found that economic development and population migration affects provincial housing inequality significantly. Research confirms that housing inequality in China is increasing, which needs the central government to promote housing reform and alleviate the contradiction of housing interests.

sociology,social sciences, interdisciplinary
Housing Price, Consumption, and Financial Market: Evidence from Urban Household Data in China

Eddie C. M. Hui,Zhaoyingzi Dong,Shenghua Jia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1061/(asce)up.1943-5444.0000431

IF: 2.361

2018-01-01

Journal of Urban Planning and Development

Abstract:This paper aims to establish a new integrated analytic framework, within which to analyze the relationship between housing price and household consumption, financial market, and household characteristics (homeownership and credit conditions) to explore how to use these links to help industry optimization and urban development in the long run. The authors first present a behavioral economic model to show the asymmetric responses of consumption to housing price and the heterogeneous role of financial marketization across different household groups. Then, based on China Family Panel Studies (CFPS) 2010, 2012, and 2014, the authors find urban housing price influences some nonessential expenditure items like education, medical, and transportation, but such influence is subject to financial marketization. Further, the positive moderating effect of financial marketization on consumption is significant on homeowners, particularly for those being constrained. However, this moderating effect is not significant among renters. These heterogeneous responses offer meaningful implications for policy makers in formulating relevant long-term economic strategies that not only spearhead industry optimization and financial policy reform but also transform housing wealth into consumption, along with bolstering economic development in China. (C) 2018 American Society of Civil Engineers.
Housing ownership and housing wealth: new evidence in transitional China

Lili Wu,Yang Bian,Wei Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02673037.2018.1458291

2018-04-25

Housing Studies

Abstract:Ever since housing was transformed from the most important welfare benefit to the most valuable form of private property through radical housing reform in 1998, housing allocation mechanisms in China have been characterized by the coexistence of market logic and socialist legacy. Thus, the Chinese housing system exhibits a transitional nature as the country moves away from a socialist housing system towards a privatized housing system. Using the 2011 Chinese Household Finance Survey, we not only examine these changes in private ownership of housing, but also give an updated evaluation of the privatization process with new empirical evidence. We develop a conceptual framework and an empirical analysis to shed light on distinct housing inequality patterns in transitional urban China. Our results show that both socioeconomic characteristics and socialist institutions contribute to housing inequality, but they follow different paths in the reform and have different impacts on housing inequality.

environmental studies,regional & urban planning,urban studies
Housing Costs and Regional Income Inequality in China and the U.S

Brian Reinbold,Yi Wen

2018-01-01

Abstract:In this article, we look at regional per capita disposable income data for China, a developing nation, and the U.S., an advanced economy, to see how income inequality compares between two large countries with a substantial income gap.
Recent Housing Affordability in Urban China: A Comprehensive Overview

Keyang Li,Yu Qin,Jing Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chieco.2019.101362

IF: 4.744

2019-01-01

China Economic Review

Abstract:In this study, we provide a comprehensive overview of housing affordability in China from both the macro and micro perspectives. We extend the scope of housing affordability analysis to all Chinese cities based on a unique panel dataset in 275 Chinese prefecture cities from 2014 to 2018. We also make a novel methodological contribution to the literature by employing micro-level data from an anonymous major Chinese city in 2015. Our results suggest that the overall level of housing affordability in Chinese cities remained relatively stable or even improved during the sample period. However, we identify a few “superstar cities,” such as Beijing, Shanghai, Shenzhen, and Xiamen, which are associated with a serious housing affordability problem. This problem arises from both a shortage of supply in the space market and a potential mispricing in the asset market, and may have a spillover effect on surrounding cities due to home purchase restrictions in the superstar cities. Within these cities, the housing affordability problem leads to longer commuting time due to the separation of home and workplace, and lower housing space consumption for the residents.
Housing In Beijing Urban Villages And Migrants' Income Patterns

Zhang Bo

2010-01-01

Abstract:Housing units in urban villages meet the enormous demand for cheap housing of migrant workers in cities. Such housing is quite different from the formal housing in terms of physical attributes, spatial distribution and other features. Using a unique data set from Beijing urban village survey (50 urban villages, 998 observations, 583 valid samples for analysis), this paper examines the living conditions and income patterns of migrant workers in Beijing urban villages. Housing rent per unit in urban villages is very low, which is explained by the small dwelling size per unit. Per-unit-space rent in urban villages is similar with that in the nearby formal housing projects, and also has a similar spatial gradient with that of the formal housing. In addition, the paper finds that migrant workers' average one-way commuting time is about 20 minutes, far below that of the average urban residents in Beijing (43 minutes), and migrant workers' income have a similar spatial gradient with that of per-unit-space rent in urban villages, which can explain the spatial distribution of housing in Beijing urban villages, and may be explained by the spatial dispersion of the low-skill job opportunities and migrant workers' low preference for public goods and services. The stylized facts provided by this paper have some implications for the provision of public rental housing to low-skill migrant workers.
Land Supply and Housing Prices in Beijing: An Intra-City Analysis

Siqi Zheng,Weizeng Sun,Rui Wang

2012-01-01

Abstract:China’s rapid urbanization is accompanied by the rocket rise in residential property price. Significant spatial disparities in housing price and its growth rate are observed in Beijing. This paper examines the quantity and price effects of residential land availability in Beijing. Using datasets of residential land leases and private housing resale records from 2006 to 2009, we find smaller new residential land supply and higher housing price where land supply is more constrained after controlling for demand-side factors. The capitalization of school quality and subway accessibility is also larger in supply-constrained locations. We discuss the limitations of this study and policy implications in conclusion.
Income and Consumption Inequality in Urban China: 1992–2003

Hongbin Cai,Yuyu Chen,Li‐An Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/650423

IF: 2

2010-01-01

Economic Development and Cultural Change

Abstract:Using the nationally representative Urban Household Income and Expenditure Survey (UHIES) conducted by the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) of China, we document a steadily rising trend in income and consumption inequality during the period from 1992 to 2003 in urban China. Despite the rising urban inequality over time, the social welfare of urban residents unambiguously improved because every income group saw their income and consumption increase over this period (higher income groups experienced faster increases). Moreover, consumption inequality follows income inequality very closely. Labor income inequality accounts for about two‐thirds of total income inequality quite consistently over time. We find that only about one‐third of urban inequality can be attributed to observable individual choices and characteristics, of which education has increasing explanatory power, while regional differences become less important over time. We also find that restructuring of the SOE sector, urbanization, and globalization are important contributing factors to rising overall urban inequality and the within‐group inequality not accounted for by observable individual choices and characteristics.

Income Inequality and Housing Affordability in Beijing - an Empirical Study from Household Survey

The Impact of Privatization of Public Housing on Housing Affordability in Beijing: an Assessment Using Household Survey Data

Decomposition Analysis on Income Inequality in Urban China

The Affordability of Owner Occupied Housing in Beijing

Housing Inequality in Urban China

Affordability of Housing and Accessibility of Public Services: Evaluation of Housing Programs in Beijing

Job-Accessibility-Based Housing Affordability Index: An Application In Beijing

From Income and Housing Wealth Inequalities to Emissions Inequality: Carbon Emissions of Households in China

Affordability Index for Transportation and Housing:An Application in Beijing

Housing Affordability and Housing Vacancy in China: the Role of Income Inequality

Evaluation of Affordability and Accessibility of Public Rental Housing: A Case study of Beijing

Examining spatial pattern and location choice of affordable housing in Beijing, China: Developing a workable assessment framework

Housing Inequality in Urban China: Theoretical Debates, Empirical Evidences, and Future Directions

Multi-dimensional Housing Inequality Index: The Provincial Evidence from China

Housing Price, Consumption, and Financial Market: Evidence from Urban Household Data in China

Housing ownership and housing wealth: new evidence in transitional China

Housing Costs and Regional Income Inequality in China and the U.S

Recent Housing Affordability in Urban China: A Comprehensive Overview

Housing In Beijing Urban Villages And Migrants' Income Patterns

Land Supply and Housing Prices in Beijing: An Intra-City Analysis

Income and Consumption Inequality in Urban China: 1992–2003