Symbolic or Substantive: Globalization Imprinting and Innovation in China

Daxin Sun,Saixing Zeng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2022.13203abstract

2022-01-01

Abstract:By integrating the imprinting theory and the literature on innovation strategies and symbolic management, this study has developed a theoretical framework by identifying a key organizational imprinting: globalization imprinting, and empirically tested whether and why this specific imprinting affects two distinct innovative behaviors: symbolic and substantive. Furthermore, we highlight how two different logics influence such an innovation decoupling: (1) How do firms vary in symbolic innovation or substantive innovation through the state logic such as state ownership and political hierarchy; (2) How do firms behave differently in symbolic or substantive innovation through the competitive logic such as FDI and complexity of technology sector. We test our theory in the context of Chinese publicly listed firms in manufacturing sector from 2002 to 2015. We find that global imprinting actually facilitates both firms’ symbolic and substantive innovation. Moreover, such a positive relationship between globalization imprinting and symbolic innovation is more pronounced when firms are state-owned or affiliated with higher political hierarchy, while things are the opposite for the substantive innovation. we further find that the positive relationship between globalization imprinting and substantive innovation is more pronounced when firms are located in regions attracting more foreign direct investments. Our findings contribute to the knowledge of organizational imprinting, advance the understanding of globalization for transitional economies, and provide novel insights into forms of strategic innovations.