Naturalistic Covert Progression Behind Complicated Plot: Chopin's "A Pair of Silk Stockings"
Dan Shen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/jnt.2022.0002
2022-01-01
Journal of Narrative Theory
Abstract:Naturalistic Covert Progression Behind Complicated Plot:Chopin's "A Pair of Silk Stockings" Dan Shen (bio) In interpreting a literary work, we usually investigate what thematic message is conveyed by textual choices in the plot-based narrative progression (which may have different branches or layers). But in many fictional narratives, there exists what I have designated a "covert progression," a hidden narrative movement that constitutes a separate trajectory of signification and that parallels the plot development throughout the text (Shen, "Covert/Plot," "'Covert'/Dual"). This undercurrent conveys contrastive or even opposite thematic significance, character images and aesthetic values in relation to the plot development, and thus it complicates or has the potential to complicate readers' responses in various ways. Significantly, "covert progression" is different from all other types of deeper-level meaning as previously investigated, including "submerged plot" (Marsh, Submerged), "submerged narrative" (Guth), "second story" (Mortimer), and two different senses of "covert plot" (Watts; Richter). The other concepts, for all their divergent references, invariably operate within the realm of the plot development (Shen, "'Covert'/Dual" 3–6). By contrast, my interest in covert progression "takes a step beyond the heritage of Aristotelian poetics in that it diverges from the traditional emphasis on plot to explore textual undercurrents running parallel to and sometimes counter to the plot development" (Pier 123). The relationship between covert and overt progressions varies from [End Page 1] narrative to narrative, ranging from harmonious complementation to drastic subversion (Shen, "'Covert'/Dual" 6–19). No matter to what degree they are in conflict or in harmony, covert progression and plot development are always two distinct narrative movements, each standing on its own. That is why "[r]eading for the plot has blinded us to the possibility of covert progressions that either expand or subvert the meanings that emerge from a purely plot-centered reading" (Abbott, "Thoughts" 64).1 The present study argues that there is a naturalistic covert progression behind the complicated plot development in Kate Chopin's "A Pair of Silk Stockings" (1897), which pertains to a "complementary" type of relation. In this narrative, although the covert progression is constantly in conflict with the plot development, they join hands in conveying the total thematic meaning of the work and in portraying a complicated image of the female protagonist. Interestingly, in this narrative by Chopin, the plot development itself contains at least two overt thematic trajectories, with a covert progression unobtrusively paralleling them. This is both similar to and in contrast with Edgar Allan Poe's "The Tell-Tale Heart" (1843), where there are also three parallel thematic trajectories (Shen, Style 29–49). In the latter narrative, textual choices crucial or important in one trajectory of signification often become peripheral or digressive in another, or vice versa, but they seldom generate conflicting meanings since the three trajectories share the same general ethic or thematic orientation. By contrast, in Chopin's "A Pair of Silk Stockings," textual choices often simultaneously convey conflicting meanings because they function at once in three thematically incompatible trajectories. What is more, while two trajectories are covertly hidden behind the overt plot in Poe's narrative, in Chopin's we have only one covert progression behind two overt ones. Paying attention only to any one of the parallel trajectories of signification, regardless of which one, will result in a one-sided picture of the thematic significance, character image, aesthetic value, and cultural influence of the narrative. Although covert progression is found at least as early as in Poe's 1843 "The Tell-Tale Heart," it seems to be quite typical of the American short story form in the 1890s.2 In fact, covert progression behind the plot development is also a feature of some other stories by Kate Chopin, such as "Désirée's Baby" and "La Belle Zoraïde" (Shen, Style 70–94, "Dual Narrative").3 But of course, covert progression is not a narrative strategy limited [End Page 2] to one period or genre. It also appears, for instance, in modern short stories,4 modern and contemporary drama (Marsh, "Dual"; Zhang), contemporary comics (Candel), and contemporary novels (An; Lothe). Kate Chopin's "A Pair of Silk Stockings" is already "one of her...