In-group Favoritism or Black Sheep Effect? the Moderating Role of Norm Strength on Destination Residents' Responses Towards Deviant Behaviors

Lujun Su,Huixuan Chen,Yinghua Huang,Xiuqiong Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tourman.2023.104773
IF: 12.879
2023-01-01
Tourism Management
Abstract:Drawing on social identity theory and focus theory of norms, this study investigated differences in how desti-nation residents respond to deviant behaviors by other residents-members of their in-group-and similar behavior by tourists, who they see as the out-group. We proposed and tested a conceptual model of the transition between in-group favoritism and the black sheep effect under the moderating effect of norm strength. A mixed -method approach, including a secondary data study and three scenario-based experiments, was applied. Findings of this study revealed that focal residents showed in-group favoritism for other residents' deviant behavior compared with tourists. The contagion effect of deviant behavior was stronger among in-groups than out-groups. However, with respect to behaviors about which norms are tight, the black sheep effect comes into play, as focal residents hold a higher desire to punish in-groups' deviant behavior than the out-group. This study has theo-retical and practical implications for destination marketing organizations.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?