Abstract:This article examines how civil society organizations navigate local government to secure more inclusive environmental governance. Based on an in-depth case study of water governance in Zhejiang Province between 2012 and 2018, we find that Green Zhejiang, a civil society organization, exercised informal power to hold the local government accountable based on two strategies: mobilizing citizens to collect information on water pollution and strategically leveraging the authority of provincial government to find citizen-focused solutions. Most existing studies foreground one stage of the policy process - advocacy in the agenda-setting phase, policy entrepreneurship during the design phase, or monitoring during the implementation phase; however, we examine strategies of civil society organizations throughout this policy lifecycle. With this approach, we are able to analyse the strategic interactions between different levels of the government and civil society organizations and locate the positive outcomes and limits under the current governance system. Despite policy successes, Green Zhejiang still acts informally, which limits long-term effectiveness. However, incorporating citizens into public administration in a meaningful way requires sharing policymaking power formally, and thus far, local governments are only willing to share power in an ad hoc and informal way. More institutionalized citizen participation is necessary to develop innovative solutions to the severe environmental degradation in China.

"Crouching Tiger, Hidden Power": A 25-Year Strategic Advocacy Voyage of an Environmental NGO in China

Environmental public interest litigation: new roles for civil society organizations in environmental governance in China

Civic Engagement and Sustainable Development in Urban China: Policy Lobbying by Social Organizations

State Power And Nongovernmental Organizations' Policy Advocacy In China

Civil society organizations in China: Navigating the local government for more inclusive environmental governance

Environmental Advocacy in a Globalising China: Non-Governmental Organisation Engagement with the Green Belt and Road Initiative

Participation Without Contestation: NGOs' Autonomy and Advocacy in China

On Ways Ahead for NGOs

When Little Fish Encounter a Big Dam

On China′s Environmental Movements and Their Strategic Choice in the Perspective of "political Opportunity Structure"

Nongovernmental Organizations’ Policy Advocacy and Government Responsiveness in China

The Emergence of Ngos in China and Their Transnational Linkages: Implications for Domestic Reform

Frame Alignment and Environmental Advocacy: the Influence of NGO Strategies on Policy Outcomes in China

Publicity Strategies and Media Logic: Communication Campaigns of Environmental Ngos in China

The Organizational Ecology of an Educational NGO

The Change of Agenda-setting Models:A Case Study of Advocacy Activities by Environmental NGOs in China

All Roads Lead to Rome: Autonomy, Political Connections and Organisational Strategies of Ngos in China

Advocacy groups in China's environmental policymaking: Pathways to influence

Advocacy by Chinese Nonprofit Organisations: Towards A Responsive Government?

From outsiders to insiders: the rise of China ENGOs as new experts in the law-making process and the building of a technocratic representation

Non-Governmental Organisations’ Policy Advocacy in China: Resources, Government Intention and Network