Abstract:Digitalization has expanded the scope of citizen participation. Nevertheless, there are no conclusive findings on online citizen participation and inclusive policymaking. This study adds in line with the discussion with a fresh perspective of institutional bias. It presents new evidence by examining the process, participants, policy agenda, and sentiments of public opinions from the government-led and Internet-empowered citizen participation regarding the 2017–2035 Shanghai Master Plan. Four findings are reported based on the in-depth case study with text and sentiment analysis. First, the government-led model provides institutionalized opportunities for citizen engagement throughout the policy process, while the Internet-empowered citizen participation is characterized by contingency and ad hoc. Second, the government-led model remains elite-dominated, while the Internet empowers a wider scope of stakeholders with an open and popularized participation platform. Third, the public opinion from the Internet-empowered model often goes beyond or even against the pre-defined official principles and goals. In contrast, the civic discussion in the government-led model influences policy by changing the sequence of policy agenda or providing focus within the official setting. Fourth, citizens, especially the experts, are more likely to give positive feedback in the government-led model than the Internet-empowered approach. These findings confirm and identify the remaining institutional bias that hinders inclusive policymaking in the Internet age. Theoretically, it reminds scholars to examine the institutional arrangements regarding citizen participation carefully. Practically, it indicates that the central government could facilitate inclusive policymaking at the local level by reducing the institutional bias of the government-led approach and utilizing text and sentiment analysis to urge the local government's response to Internet-empowered public opinion.

Civic Engagement and Sustainable Development in Urban China: Policy Lobbying by Social Organizations

Nongovernmental Organizations’ Policy Advocacy and Government Responsiveness in China

Non-Governmental Organisations’ Policy Advocacy in China: Resources, Government Intention and Network

Civil society organizations in China: Navigating the local government for more inclusive environmental governance

Participation Without Contestation: NGOs' Autonomy and Advocacy in China

Environmental public interest litigation: new roles for civil society organizations in environmental governance in China

Government-led and Internet-empowered Citizen Participation in China's Policymaking: A Case Study of the Shanghai 2035 Master Plan.

Advocacy by Chinese Nonprofit Organisations: Towards A Responsive Government?

The rising of media-oriented civil society in China: How grassroot voices influence policy agenda

State Power And Nongovernmental Organizations' Policy Advocacy In China

The Emergence of Ngos in China and Their Transnational Linkages: Implications for Domestic Reform

Emerging environmental Multi-Level Governance in China? Environmental protests, public participation and local institution-building

New Strategies of Civil Society in China: a case study of the network governance approach

Environmental Advocacy in a Globalising China: Non-Governmental Organisation Engagement with the Green Belt and Road Initiative

The interactive field of open government data: inter-administrative dynamics, trans-local networks, and local geopolitics of environmental data activism in China

What Motivates Local Sustainability Policy Action in China? the Case of Low-Carbon City Pilot Program

Understanding Individual Environmental Concern in the Context of Local Environmental Governance in China: A Multi-Level Analysis

Local Government and NGOs in China: Performance-Based Collaboration

Citizen Participation in China’s Eco-City Development. Will ‘New-Type Urbanization’ Generate a Breakthrough in Realizing It?

Does the Squeaky Wheel Get More Grease? The Direct and Indirect Effects of Citizen Participation on Environmental Governance in China

Partnership building? Government-led NGO participation in China’s grassroots waste governance