Abstract:Background: Criminal defendants may often exaggerate psychiatric symptoms either to appear non-accountable for their actions or to mitigate their imprisonment. Several psychometric tests have been proposed to detect malingering. These instruments are often validated by Simulation Design (SD) protocols, where normal participants are explicitly requested to either simulate a mental disorder or respond honestly. However, the real scenarios (clinical or forensic) are often very challenging because of the presence of genuine patients, so that tests accuracy frequently differs from that one obtained in well-controlled experimental settings. Here we assessed the effectiveness in criminal defendants of three well-known malingering-detecting tests (MMPI-2, SIMS and NIM) by using both Known-Group Comparison (KGC) and Simulation Design (SD) protocols. Methods: The study involved 151 male inmates. Participants to the KGC protocol were all characterized by a positive psychiatric history. They were considered as genuine patients (KGC_Controls) if they had some psychiatric disorders already before imprisonment and scored above the cutoff of SCL-90-R, a commonly used test for mental illness, and as suspected malingerers (KGC_SM) if they were diagnosed as psychiatric patients only after imprisonment and scored below the SCL-90-R cutoff. Participants to SD protocol had no history of psychiatric disease and scored below the SCL-90-R cutoff. They were randomly assigned to either group: Controls (requested to answer honestly, SD_Controls) and simulated malingerers (requested to feign a psychiatric disease, SD_SM). All participants were then submitted to MMPI-2, NIM and SIMS. Results: Results showed that while MMPI-2, SIMS and NIM were all effective in discriminating malingerers in the SD, SIMS only significantly discriminated between KGC_Controls and KGC_SM in the Known-Group Comparison. Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curves analysis confirmed the better sensitivity of SIMS with respect to the other tests but raised some issues on SIMS specificity. Discussion: Results support the sensitivity of SIMS for the detection of malingering in forensic populations. However, some specificity issues emerged suggesting that further research and a good forensic practice should keep into account multiple measures of malingering, including psychometric data, clinical and social history and current clinical situation. These methodological constraints must be kept in mind during detection of malingering in criminal defendants reporting psychiatric symptoms.

Signal detection analysis of affective prosody recognition in forensic inpatients who have committed sexual offenses

Recognition of dynamic facial expressions of emotions in forensic inpatients who have committed sexual offenses: a signal detection analysis

Recognition of facial emotion and perceived parental bonding styles in healthy volunteers and personality disorder patients.

Processing of emotional faces in sexual offenders with and without child victims: An eye-tracking study with pupillometry

Psychopathy, criminogenic cognitions and emotional responses to affective stimuli among male adult offenders

Comprehension of affective prosody in women with post-traumatic stress disorder related to childhood abuse

Cognitive predictors of violent incidents in forensic psychiatric inpatients

Cognitive Impairment and Emotional Dysregulation in Offenders

Detecting malingering mental illness in forensics: Known-Group Comparison and Simulation Design with MMPI-2, SIMS and NIM

Low sadness and high happiness facial prevalence to others' suffering in intimate partner violence against women perpetrators: influence of emotional decoding deficits

Categorization and evaluation of emotional faces in psychopathic women

Facial emotion recognition and judgment of affective scenes in Parkinson's disease

Understanding criminal behavior: Empathic impairment in criminal offenders

RECOGNITION OF EMOTIONS FROM VOICE IN MILD COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT AND ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE DEMENTIA

Psychopathy and functional magnetic resonance imaging blood oxygenation level-dependent responses to emotional faces in violent patients with schizophrenia

Diagnostic Performance of Socio-Emotional Informant-Based Questionnaires for the Clinical Detection of the Behavioral Variant of Frontotemporal Dementia

How to assess emotional recognition in individuals with a diagnosis of schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders: a pilot study

Assessment of the Standard Forensic Procedure for the Evaluation of Psychological Injury in Intimate-Partner Violence

Detecting Apathy in Older Adults with Cognitive Disorders Using Automatic Speech Analysis

Relationships between social withdrawal and facial emotion recognition in neuropsychiatric disorders

Application of Facial Expression Analysis Technology in Violence Risk Assessment of Individuals with Mental Disorders in Supervised Settings