Abstract:The standard approach in neuroscience research infers from the external stimulus (outside) to the brain (inside) through stimulus-evoked activity. Recently challenged by Buzsáki, he advocates the reverse; an inside-out approach inferring from the brain’s activity to the neural effects of the stimulus. If so, stimulus-evoked activity should be a hybrid of internal and external components. Providing direct evidence for this hybrid nature, we measured human intracranial stereo-electroencephalography (sEEG) to investigate how prestimulus variability, i.e., standard deviation, shapes poststimulus activity through trial-to-trial variability. We first observed greater poststimulus variability quenching in trials exhibiting high prestimulus variability. Next, we found that the relative effect of the stimulus was higher in the later (300-600ms) than the earlier (0-300ms) poststimulus period. These results were extended by our Deep Learning LSTM network models at the single trial level. The accuracy to classify single trials (prestimulus low/high) increased greatly when the models were trained and tested with real trials compared to trials that exclude the effects of the prestimulus-related ongoing dynamics (corrected trials). Lastly, we replicated our findings showing that trials with high prestimulus variability in theta and alpha bands exhibits faster reaction times. Together, our results support the inside-out approach by demonstrating that stimulus-related activity is a hybrid of two factors: 1) the effects of the external stimulus itself, and 2) the effects of the ongoing dynamics spilling over from the prestimulus period, with the second, i.e., the inside, dwarfing the influence of the first, i.e., the outside. B. Significance Statement Our findings signify a significant conceptual advance in the relationship between pre- and poststimulus dynamics in humans. These findings are important as they show that we miss an essential component - the impact of the ongoing dynamics - when restricting our analyses to the effects of the external stimulus alone. Consequently, these findings may be crucial to fully understand higher cognitive functions and their impairments, as can be seen in psychiatric illnesses. In addition, our Deep Learning LSTM models show a second conceptual advance: high classification accuracy of a single trial to its prestimulus state. Finally, our replicated results in an independent dataset and task showed that this relationship between pre- and poststimulus dynamics exists across tasks and is behaviorally relevant.

Feature-specific Reactivations of Past Information Shift Current Neural Encoding Thereby Mediating Serial Bias Behaviors

Co-occurrence of past and present shifts current neural representations and mediates serial biases

Reactivated past decisions repel early sensory processing and attract late decision-making

Cross-Modal Interaction and Integration Through Stimulus-Specific Adaptation in the Thalamic Reticular Nucleus of Rats.

Systematic changes in neural selectivity reflect the acquired salience of category-diagnostic dimensions

Feature-specific Cortical Plasticity after Rapid Perceptual Learning During Speech Segregation: a MEG Study

Serial Dependence in Perceptual Decisions Is Reflected in Activity Patterns in Primary Visual Cortex

Domain General Change Detection Accounts for "dishabituation" Effects in Temporal-Parietal Regions in Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Studies of Speech Perception.

Diverse perceptual biases emerge from Hebbian plasticity in a recurrent neural network model

Emergent perceptual biases from state-space geometry in trained spiking recurrent neural networks

Cortical reactivations predict future sensory responses

The Hybrid Nature of Task-Evoked Activity: Inside-out Neural Dynamics in Intracranial EEG and Deep Learning

Dynamic Modulation of Representational Trajectories Through Selective Attention

Neural evidence for decision-making underlying attractive serial dependence

Rapid and long-lasting improvements in neural discrimination of acoustic signals with passive familiarization

Selective corticostriatal plasticity during acquisition of an auditory discrimination task

Concurrent Encoding of Frequency and Amplitude Modulation in Human Auditory Cortex: Encoding Transition.

Long-horizon associative learning explains human sensitivity to statistical and network structures in auditory sequences

Temporal Configuration as a New Feature of Sound: Psychological and Neurophysiological Evidence, Cross-species Consistency and Underlying Neuronal Mechanisms

Study-Phase Reinstatement: Encoding Spontaneous Thoughts as Memories

Temporal asymmetry of neural representations predicts memory decisions