Abstract:Much of researchers' efforts to foster wider implementation of educational innovations in STEM has focused on understanding and facilitating the implementation efforts of faculty. However, student engagement in blended learning and other innovations relies heavily on students' self-directed learning behaviors, implying that students are likely key actors in the implementation process. This paper explores the ways in which engineering students at multiple institutions experience the self-directed selection and implementation of blended learning resources in the context of their own studies. To accomplish this, it adopts a research perspective informed by Actor-Network Theory, allowing students themselves to be perceived as individual actors and implementors rather than a population that is implemented upon. A thematic analysis was conducted in two parts. First, analysis identified sets of themes unique to the student experience at four participant institutions. Then, a second round of analysis identified and explored a subset of key actors represented in students' reported experiences across all institutions. The findings show clear similarities and differences in students' experiences of blended learning across the four institutions, with many themes echoing or building upon the results of prior research. Distinct institutional traits, the actions of the instructors, the components of the blended learning environment, and the unique needs and preferences of the students themselves all helped to shape students' self-directed learning experiences. Students' engagement decisions and subsequent implementations of blended learning resulted in personally appropriate, perhaps even idiosyncratic, forms of engagement with their innovative learning opportunities. The institutional implementation of blended learning, and perhaps other educational innovations, relies in part on the self-directed decision-making of individual students. This suggests that instructors too hold an additional responsibility: to act as facilitators of their students' implementation processes and as catalysts for growth and change in students' learning behaviors. Developing a greater understanding of students' implementation behaviors could inform the future implementation efforts of faculty and better empower students to succeed in the innovative classroom.

From Initiators to Free-Riders: Exploring the Spectrum of Female Engineering Students' Functional Roles in Project-Based Learning using Phenomenography

The Importance of Collaborative Design for Narrowing the Gender Gap in Engineering: An Analysis of Engineering Identity Development in Elementary Students

Engineering student experience and self-direction in implementations of blended learning: a cross-institutional analysis

Preliminary Study on Students’ Experiences in Design-Based Interdisciplinary Learning

Gendered Risks of Team-Based Learning: A Model of Inequitable Task Allocation in Project-Based Learning

Effects of a first-year undergraduate engineering design course: survey study of implications for student self-efficacy and professional skills, with focus on gender/sex and race/ethnicity

Sources contributing to engineering students' academic well‐being: An exploration using the Q methodology

The role of gender in Chinese junior high students' self-efficacy, creative thinking and project-based learning perceived value in technology and engineering education

First-Year Design Projects and Student Perceptions of the Role of an Engineer

Understanding the role of peer pressure on engineering students' learning behavior: A TPB perspective

Examining engineering students' perceptions of learner agency enactment in problem‐ and project‐based learning using Q methodology

Online project-based learning in engineering design: Supporting the acquisition of design skills

The Types of Learning Approaches Used by Engineering Students in Three Scenarios: An Adaptation of the R-SPQ-2F to China

Understanding the relationship between idea contributions and idea enactments in student design teams: A social network analysis approach

A longitudinal analysis of students' motivational characteristics in introductory physics courses: Gender differences

Group Dynamics in Inquiry-based Labs: Gender Inequities and the Efficacy of Partner Agreements

A narrative inquiry into developing learner agency of engineering students in an intercultural PBL environment

Gender Differences in Teamwork and Leadership within Virtual Engineering Laboratories

What Drives Undergraduate Engineering Students to Engage in Project Based Learning: A Case of Curriculum Reform in a Chinese University

Leadership Development in Women STEM Students: The Interplay of Task Behaviors, Self-Efficacy, and University Training

“We learn things to solve real-life problems”: Understanding how nature of engineering beliefs situate developing pedagogical content knowledge in a modular engineering education professional development program