Abstract:A large number of theoretical and experimental studies have shown that punishment and voluntary participation can promote cooperation, which offers an explanation for the emergence of cooperation. In this paper, individuals can freely choose whether to participate in the public goods game, and cooperators perform both cooperation and punishment. On the one hand, cooperators invest in public goods, and on the other hand, they punish the defectors and share the cost of punishment. Furthermore, considering the impact of population structure, we investigate the evolution of cooperation in well-mixed populations with the replicator dynamics and structured populations with the Fermi update rule, respectively. Our results indicate that the evolution of cooperation is obviously different between the two populations. In well-mixed populations, the voluntary participation mechanism prevents defection from becoming an evolutionary stable strategy. When the fine is low, the strategy of non-participation will be the only evolutionary stable strategy. With the increase of the fine, both cooperation and non-participation will be the evolutionary stable strategies. When the fine is high, cooperation will become the only evolutionary stable strategy. In structured populations, cooperators, defectors and loners can coexist under mild punishment, which means that population structure is favorable to the emergence of cooperation. However, cooperators occupy the population with higher fine threshold compared to well-mixed populations, which indicates that population structure is not always favorable to the evolution of cooperation.

Voluntary participation boosts cooperation in repeated multiplayer games

Evolutionary dynamics in repeated optional games

The Evolution of Cooperation in Spatial Multigame with Voluntary Participation

Multigames with Voluntary Participation on Interdependent Networks and the Evolution of Cooperation

The Evolution of Cooperation Affected by Aspiration-Driven Updating Rule in Multi-Games with Voluntary Participation

Effects of Reciprocal Rewarding on the Evolution of Cooperation in Voluntary Social Dilemmas

Benefits of Asynchronous Exclusion for the Evolution of Cooperation in Stochastic Evolutionary Optional Public Goods Games

Optional participation only provides a narrow scope for sustaining cooperation

The Effect Of Strategy Retention On Cooperation Based On Multi-Game In Complex Environment

Cooperation and Control in Multiplayer Social Dilemmas

Opting out Against Defection Leads to Stable Coexistence with Cooperation

Bounded Rationality in Volunteering Public Goods Games.

Evolutionary Performance of Zero-Determinant Strategies in Multiplayer Games.

Reinforcement learning facilitates an optimal interaction intensity for cooperation

Reputation-based Mutual Selection Rule Promotes Cooperation in Spatial Threshold Public Goods Games

The evolution of cooperation in voluntary public goods game with shared-punishment

The Effect of Bounded Rationality on Human Cooperation with Voluntary Participation

Fostering Cooperation of Selfish Agents Through Public Goods in Relation to the Loners

Promoting Cooperation by Setting a Ceiling Payoff for Defectors under Three-Strategy Public Good Games.

Cooperation in costly-access environments