Evolutionary dynamics in repeated optional games

Fang Chen,Lei Zhou,Long Wang

2023-11-16

Abstract:Direct reciprocity facilitates the evolution of cooperation when individuals interact repeatedly. Most previous studies on direct reciprocity implicitly assume compulsory interactions. Yet, interactions are often voluntary in human societies. Here, we consider repeated optional games, where individuals can freely opt out of each interaction and rejoin later. We find that voluntary participation greatly promotes cooperation in repeated interactions, even in harsh situations where repeated compulsory games and one-shot optional games yield low cooperation rates. Moreover, we theoretically characterize all Nash equilibria that support cooperation among reactive strategies, and identify three novel classes of strategies that are error-robust, readily become equilibria, and dominate in the evolutionary dynamics. The success of these strategies hinges on the effect of opt-out: it not only avoids trapping in mutual defection but also poses additional threats to intentional defectors. Our work highlights that voluntary participation is a simple and effective mechanism to enhance cooperation in repeated interactions.

Physics and Society,Populations and Evolution

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how voluntary participation promotes the evolution of cooperation in repeated optional games. Specifically, the paper explores that in human society, interactions between individuals are often voluntary rather than compulsory. In this case, an individual can choose not to participate in an interaction and re - join later. The paper studies how this voluntary participation mechanism affects the evolution of cooperative behavior, especially in situations where repeated compulsory games and one - time optional games lead to a low cooperation rate.

Through theoretical analysis and simulation experiments, the paper identifies three new strategy categories (OD - TFT, DO - OFT and OD - TFT C). These strategies can not only support cooperation, but also are robust to implementation errors, are likely to become Nash equilibria, and dominate in the evolutionary dynamics. The success of these strategies lies in their effective use of the "exit" option to counteract betrayal behavior, which not only avoids getting into a situation of mutual betrayal, but also poses an additional threat to deliberate betrayers.

In addition, the paper also explores the impact of exit payoffs (i.e., the rewards obtained when choosing to exit) on the evolution of cooperation. It is found that a relatively small exit payoff is sufficient to achieve a high level of cooperation, while an overly high exit payoff will instead inhibit cooperation, because at this time individuals are more inclined to choose to exit to obtain a stable income rather than take risks to cooperate. This finding emphasizes the importance of voluntary participation as a simple and effective mechanism for enhancing cooperation in repeated interactions.