The significance of high risk human papillomavirus detection and liquid-based cytology test and their combination analysis for cervical cancer screening
Rui-zhen LI,Rui-fang WU,Na WULAN,Zhi-hong LIU,Yan-qiu ZHOU,Chang-huai ZHANG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1007-3639.2008.03.007
2008-01-01
Abstract:Background and purpose:Hybrid capture Ⅱ(HC-Ⅱ) human papillomavirus(HPV) test and liquid-based cytology test(LCT) are two main methods for cervical cancer screening at present.It is reported that the combination of HC Ⅱ HPV and LCT can improve the detection rate of cervical cancer screening.Selecting economic and effective method for cervical cancer screening to decrease morbidity of cervical cancer is receiving more and more concern.This study was to evaluate the function of HC-Ⅱ HPV and LCT and their combination plan for cervical high-grade lesions screening and to guide in selecting the scheme of cervical cancer screening. Methods :HC-Ⅱ HPV and LCT were performed in 2 471 women treated in Shenzhen Hospital of Peking University from May 2003 to Dec.2005.The women with abnormal or suspicious finding on colposcopy received biopsy.Both women with HPV-positive and women with atypical squamous cells of undetermined sign(ASCUS) received biopsy under colposcopy.Both women with HPV-negative or HPV-positive and women with LCT equal to low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion(LSIL) or higher than LSIL also received biopsy under colposcopy. All biopsy in specimens were examined by pathology.HC Ⅱ HPV and LCT were performed by double blind method.The pathology results were the final diagnosis to evaluate the value of each approach for screening cervical cancer. Results :A total of 287 patients received biopsy in this study.Of the 287 patients,6 had cervical cancer,18 had cervical intraepithelial neoplasia CINⅢ,39 had CINⅡ,98 had CINⅠ,126 had other diseases(chronic cervititis and metaplasia).HPV-positive rate and LCT-positive rate were 16.8% and 11.8%,respectively.The positive rate of HPV combined with LCT was 21.2% in parallel test and 7.4% in serial test.The HPV-positive rate and LCT positive rate increased with cervical lesions grade increased(P <0.005).The sensitivity,specificity,accuracy,positive prevalue,negative prevalue,positive likelihood ratio and negative likelihood ratio of HC-Ⅱ HPV for detecting high-grade cervical lesions were 98.4%,85.3%,85.6%,14.9%,100%,6.7 and 0.02,respectively;The values for LCT were 92.1%,90.3%,90.3%,19.9%,100.0%,9.5 and 0.09,respectively;The values for HPV-LCT parallel test were 100.0%,80.8%,81.3%,12.0%,100%,5.2 and 0.0,respectively;The values for HPV-LCT serial test were 90.5%,94.8%,94.7%,31.1%,99.7%,17.4 and 0.10,respectively.The areas of under receiver operating characteristic(ROC) curves in each screening test for screening high-grade cervical lesions were 0.919,0.921,0.904 and 0.926,respectively.There were no significant differences between screening tests(P >0.05). Conclusions :Both HC-Ⅱ HPV test and LCT are valuable for screening cervical cancer at present.The combination of HC Ⅱ HPV and LCT cannot improve significantly the detection rate of cervical cancer screening,but may increase the cost of cervical cancer single screening.