In Search of a Network Theory of Innovations: Relations, Positions, and Perspectives
Loet Leydesdorff,Petra Ahrweiler
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.23127
2014-01-01
Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology
Abstract:As a complement to Nelson and Winter's (1977) article titled In Search of a Useful Theory of Innovation, a sociological perspective on innovation networks can be elaborated using Luhmann's social systems theory, on the one hand, and Latour's sociology of translations, on the other. Because of a common focus on communication, these perspectives can be combined as a set of methodologies. Latour's sociology of translations specifies a mechanism for generating variation in relations (associations), whereas Luhmann's systems perspective enables the specification of (functionally different) selection environments such as markets, professional organizations, and political control. Selection environments can be considered as mechanisms of social coordination that can self-organizebeyond the control of human agencyinto regimes in terms of interacting codes of communication. Unlike relatively globalized regimes, technological trajectories are organized locally in landscapes. A resulting duality of structure (Giddens, 1979) between the historical organization of trajectories and evolutionary self-organization at the regime level can be expected to drive innovation cycles. Reflexive translations add a third layer of perspectives to (a) the relational analysis of observable links that shape trajectories and (b) the positional analysis of networks in terms of latent dimensions. These three operations can be studied in a single framework, but using different methodologies. Latour's first-order associations can then be analytically distinguished from second-order translations in terms of requiring other communicative competencies. The resulting operations remain infrareflexively nested, and can therefore be used for innovative reconstructions of previously constructed boundaries.