Abstract:The extreme frustration in the kagome antiferromagnet makes it possible to realize a large number of closely competing magnetic phases either at the classical or the quantum level. Motivated by recent neutron scattering study on the kagome antiferromagnet vesignieite BaCu3V2O8(OH)(2), we have made systematic investigation of the phase diagram of the classical and quantum J(1) - J(3) antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model defined on the kagome lattice (KAFHM). While it is shown previously that a large antiferromagnetic exchange between the third-neighboring spins can drive an emergent q = 4 Potts order through the order-by-disorder mechanism, it is elusive what will happen in the region where the Luttinger-Tisza criteria fails to predict the classical ordering pattern. Through extensive Monte Carlo simulation, we find that such a region is characterized by competing emergent q = 3 and q = 4 Potts order, whose emergence are beyond the description of the conventional order-by-disorder mechanism. Our Schwinger boson mean-field calculation suggests the existence of the Potts-3 order in the ground state of quantum J(1) - J(3) KAFHM in such an extremely frustrated region. The predicted Potts-3 state is found to take two different forms distinguished by their projective symmetry group character (PSG or quantum order), although they have exactly the same symmetry. The transition between these two quantum orders is found to occur at a J(3) value intriguingly close to the tricritical point in the Potts-3 phase of the classical phase diagram of the model. A comparison with the exact diagonalization result on a 36-site cluster shows that the intermediate region may indeed host a nematic spin liquid ground state featuring an anisotropic ring structure around the q = 0 point in its spinon dispersion relation. We find that such an extremely frustrated region should better be taken as the playground to study the rich competition between exotic emergent phases, rather than a burden on their theoretical analysis.

Two-stage Melting of an Inter-Component Potts Long-Range Order in Two Dimensions

Partial Long-Range Order in Antiferromagnetic Potts Models

Emergent Fractional Vortices and Inter-Layer Ising Order in a Bilayer of XY Models

Competing Emergent Potts Orders and Possible Nematic Spin Liquids in the Kagome J_1-J_3 Heisenberg Model

Partial Order and Finite-Temperature Phase Transitions in Potts Models on Irregular Lattices.

Dynamical Emergence of a Potts-Nematic Superfluid in a Hexagonal $sp^2$ Optical Lattice

Phase transition in the 3-state Potts antiferromagnet on the diced lattice

Reentrance of Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless-Like Transitions in A Three-State Potts Antiferromagnetic Thin Film

Two-dimensional Potts Antiferromagnets with a Phase Transition at Arbitrarily Largeq

Competing emergent Potts orders and possible nematic spin liquids in the Kagome $J_{1}-J_{3}$ Heisenberg model

Coupled Sublattice Melting and Charge-Order Transition in Two Dimensions

Attraction Tames Two-Dimensional Melting: From Continuous to Discontinuous Transitions

Phase Transition of a Two-Dimensional, Multiplicatively Coupledxy–potts Model

Bona Fide Interaction-Driven Topological Phase Transition In Correlated Symmetry-Protected Topological States

Phase Transitions of Ferromagnetic Potts Models on the Simple Cubic Lattice

Orbital selective order and $\mathbb{Z}_3$ Potts nematicity from a non-Fermi liquid

Antiferromagnetic Ordering and Phase Transitions in the Exchange Interaction Model and the Potts Model on General Lattices

Emergent Intermediate Phase in the $J_1$-$J_2$ XY model from Tensor Network Approaches

Tensor network approach to the fully frustrated XY model on a kagome lattice with a fractional vortex-antivortex pairing transition

Phase transitions and remnants of fractionalization at finite temperature in the triangular lattice quantum loop model

Order-disorder Transitions and Inverse Melting in Vortex Lattices