Coupled Sublattice Melting and Charge-Order Transition in Two Dimensions

Tyler S. Smith,Fangfei Ming,Daniel González Trabada,César González,Diego Soler-Polo,Fernando Flores,José Ortega,Hanno H. Weitering

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.124.097602

2019-11-27

Abstract:Two-dimensional melting is one of the most fascinating and poorly understood phase transitions in nature. Theoretical investigations often point to a two-step melting scenario involving unbinding of topological defects at two distinct temperatures. Here we report on a novel melting transition of a charge-ordered K-Sn alloy monolayer on a silicon substrate. Melting starts with short-range positional fluctuations in the K sublattice while maintaining long-range order, followed by longer-range K diffusion over small domains, and ultimately resulting in a molten sublattice. Concomitantly, the charge-order of the Sn host lattice collapses in a multi-step process with both displacive and order-disorder transition characteristics. Our combined experimental and theoretical analysis provides a rare insight into the atomistic processes of a multi-step melting transition of a two-dimensional materials system.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the processes of coupled sub - lattice melting and charge - ordered transition in two - dimensional material systems. Specifically, the authors studied the unique melting transition phenomenon that occurs in the monolayer K - Sn alloy film on a silicon substrate. This melting process begins with short - range positional fluctuations in the potassium (K) sub - lattice, followed by longer - range K diffusion, and ultimately leads to the complete melting of the K sub - lattice. At the same time, the charge - ordered state in the tin (Sn) host lattice also undergoes a multi - step collapse, including displacement - type and order - disorder - type transition characteristics.

### Research Background and Problem Description

1. **Two - Dimensional Melting Phenomenon**: Two - dimensional melting is one of the most fascinating and least understood phase transitions in nature. Theoretical studies have shown that two - dimensional melting usually involves the unbinding of topological defects at two different temperatures, forming a two - step melting scenario.

2. **Experimental System**: This paper studied the monolayer K - Sn alloy film formed on a silicon substrate. Through scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and density functional theory (DFT) simulations, the researchers observed the melting process of the K sub - lattice and the collapse of the charge - ordered state of the Sn host lattice.

3. **Main Problems**:
- **Melting Mechanism of K Sub - lattice**: How does the melting of the K sub - lattice affect the structure and electronic properties of the entire system?
- **Charge - Ordered Transition of Sn Host Lattice**: How does the charge - ordered state in the Sn host lattice gradually disappear as the temperature rises?
- **Multi - step Melting Process**: Can the entire melting process be divided into multiple intermediate stages? What are the specific characteristics of each stage?

### Main Findings

1. **Short - range Fluctuation Stage**: At a lower temperature (about 130 K), short - range positional fluctuations begin to appear in the K sub - lattice, maintaining long - range order, accompanied by a partial bandgap reduction.

2. **Long - range Diffusion Stage**: As the temperature rises (about 200 K), K atoms begin to diffuse within small regions, forming liquid islands, and are accompanied by the partial melting of the charge - ordered state of the Sn host lattice.

3. **Complete Melting Stage**: At a higher temperature (about 275 K), the K sub - lattice is completely melted, and the charge - ordered state of the Sn host lattice completely collapses, showing displacement - type and order - disorder - type transitions.

### Conclusion

This study provides atomic - scale insights into the multi - step melting transition in two - dimensional material systems and reveals the driving role of K sub - lattice melting in the charge - ordered transition of the Sn host lattice. These findings not only help to understand the phase - transition mechanisms in low - dimensional materials but also provide a reference for exploring similar phenomena in other two - dimensional systems.

### Formula Display

Some physical concepts and formulas involved in the paper are as follows:

- **HOMO - LUMO Splitting**:
\[
\Delta E=E_{\text{LUMO}}-E_{\text{HOMO}}
\]
where \(E_{\text{LUMO}}\) and \(E_{\text{HOMO}}\) represent the energies of the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital and the highest occupied molecular orbital, respectively.

- **Atomic Height Difference**:
\[
\Delta z = z_{\text{up}}-z_{\text{down}}
\]
where \(z_{\text{up}}\) and \(z_{\text{down}}\) represent the heights of the Sn upper atom and the Sn lower atom, respectively.

These formulas and concepts help to explain the structural and electronic property changes of the Sn host lattice during the K sub - lattice melting process.