The robustness of low-carbon policies during China?s electricity reform

Yaoyu Zhang,Chenye Wu,Nan Gu,Yang Yu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eneco.2022.106037

IF: 12.8

2022-01-01

Energy Economics

Abstract:The progress in decarbonization that China has made coincides with its market liberalization process.However, whether the implemented and planned low-carbon policies designed before the reform will losetheir effectiveness after the reform has not been analyzed. In this research, we introduce a new dimension ofpolicy assessment into the discussion about low-carbon policies, namely, policy robustness during an economictransition. Here, robustness is used to assess whether a low-carbon policy can maintain its functions andeffectiveness during a market reform. We develop a framework and the associated metrics for policy robustnessanalysis. We apply our framework to analyze China's fuel efficiency improvement project (FEIP) and comparethe FEIP with the pricing-carbon policy (PCP) in two provinces, Guangdong and Fujian. The analysis shows thatboth the FEIP and PCP will lose some of their effectiveness during the market reform. However, implementingthe PCP is more robust than implementing the FEIP because the PCP is able to promote the fuel efficiencyimprovement of cost-competitive coal-fired generators, whose market share will expand after the reform. TheFEIP is particularly nonrobust in Fujian because of the distribution of the coal heat rates of Fujian's powerplants. We further conclude that overinvestment in generation capacity leads to less robustness of both theFEIP and PCP during the reform. There has already been overinvestment in China's power generation capacity,but the current fuel efficiency policies can be seriously nonrobust and cause significant efficiency losses duringelectricity reform