The Role of Village Spillover and Stove Use on Wintertime Outdoor PM2.5 in Villages Transitioning to Clean Heating in China

Collin Brehmer,Xiaoying Li,Talia Sternbach,Martha Lee,Xiang Zhang,Jill Baumgartner,Sam Harper,Brian Robinson,Christopher Barrington Leigh,Guofeng Shen,Yuanxun Zhang,Shu Tao,Ellison Carter
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1289/isee.2021.p-484
2021-01-01
Abstract:BACKGROUND AND AIM: In an effort to improve ambient air quality, the Beijing government is requiring that households in the municipality transition, at the village-scale, from coal-burning stoves to electric-powered heat pumps and natural gas boilers for household heating. Wintertime air quality in this region is subject to meteorological clustering and air pollution emissions from rural residential space heating with coal-burning stoves. Thus, to better understand how large-scale policies like the one being implemented perform, we conducted a village level analysis of outdoor air pollution patterning, accounting for meteorology, coverage of the policy, and home heating energy use. METHODS: We analyzed 283 1-week outdoor fine particulate matter (PM2.5) samples from 30 villages in 2 Beijing districts across 2 winter field seasons. In the first winter season (2018-2019) households in all 30 villages were heating with coal-burning stoves, whereas in the second season (2019-2020) households in 10 of those villages had ceased using coal for space heating and instead used electric heat pumps (treated). PM2.5 samples were analyzed for mass, black carbon (BC) and trace elements. Elemental and BC concentrations were included in a source apportionment model to identify the sources of elements in these villages. RESULTS:Median (interquartile range) PM2.5 concentrations (μg m-3) for treated villages were 31.2 (21.2) for season 1 and 29.7 (25.5) for season 2. For untreated villages, median concentrations were 28.8 (11.7) and 24.8 (19.0) for seasons 1 and 2, respectively. To contextualize the PM2.5 mass and source apportionment results, we discuss how these concentrations vary with respect to meteorological clustering, density of nearby treated and untreated villages, and self-reported and objective measures of home heating energy use. CONCLUSIONS:Our analysis and findings provide a framework and insights regarding influential factors that should be considered when assessing the effectiveness of similar household energy interventions. KEYWORDS: source apportionment, household energy transition, coal combustion, trace elements
What problem does this paper attempt to address?