THE EVOLUTION OF GUANXI DYNAMICS IN THE CHINESE LEGAL SYSTEM: A PERSPECTIVE OF CAREER MOBILITY

Yuqing Feng,Qing Xu
2021-01-01
Hong kong law journal
Abstract:Drawing on first-hand empirical data, this article analyses how guanxi dynamics facilitate judicial career mobility in China's legal system. Based on the varying perceptions and behaviours of judges with respect to guanxi, we distinguish guanxi dynamics: the default overt-guanxi and the emerging covert-guanxi. In the former, judges perceive guanxi as being justified by social norms and employ guanxi practice openly and sometimes abusively. In the latter, judges adopt a more prudent attitude towards guanxi and employ it in a more devious and deceptive manner. They comply with formal procedures and grant an increasingly important role to professionalism, which disguises guanxi's genuine influence and maintains formalistic legitimacy. These dynamics have evolved in step with increases in market competition, institutional certainty and political control that have occurred since the 2000s; the covert-guanxi mode is gradually supplanting the overt-guanxi mode, illustrating the continued persistence of guanxi in contemporary China.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?