Topographic data accuracy verification of small consumer UAV
ZHANG Chunbin,YANG Shengtian,ZHAO Changsen,LOU Hezhen,ZHANG Yichi,BAI Juan,WANG Zhiwei,GUAN Yabing,ZHANG Yuan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.11834/jrs.20186483
2018-01-01
Journal of Remote Sensing
Abstract:Low-altitude remote sensing recently became a hot technology with rapid development and com-prehensive application.Small consumer UAV attracted wide attention with rapid,flexible,and cost-effective ad-vantages.Large professional UAV,which is vulnerable to weather conditions,requires professional manipulation and airspace application.These factors restrict its ability to access terrain data agilely and rapidly.A small consumer UAV can compensate for large professional UAV limitations.This study comprehensively verifies the accuracy of the data obtained through this type of UAV to improve application reliability.This study focuses on the precision verification of topographic data obtained by small consumer UAV (Phantom 3 Professional).Six kinds of flight heights (50 m,60 m,70 m,80 m,90 m,and 100 m) are set to acquire a stereoscopic image and generate Point Cloud,Digital Surface Model,and Digital Orthophoto Map.Ground Control Points (GCPs) are laid out uniformly in the standard experimental field to verify measurement accuracy,and their three-dimensional coordinates are derived using differential GPS with high-precision.The absolute position of the stereoscopic images is calibrated by GCPs.Finally,the measurement accuracy of the result is analyzed using the mean error and relative root mean square error (RMSE).Results show that the resolution of the UAV image is 2.22-4.23 cm for flight height 50-100 m and will decrease with increasing flight altitude.The mean error is ± 0.51 cm in the horizontal direction and ± 4.39 cm in the vertical direction.RMSE is ± 2.79 cm in the horizontal direction and ± 9.98 cm in the vertical direction.The errors in horizontal and vertical directions are within normal distribution,but the error range is larger in the vertical direction.Five or more images in the same area are recommended when shooting to avoid errors caused by insufficient image overlap and to generate high-quality data.Simultaneously,GCPs should be evenly laid in the survey area to ensure absolute positioning accuracy and should be found in more than five images.Experimental precision can be influenced by a number of factors,such as light and weather con-ditions and flight stability.The GCP selection,measurement method,and image spike processes include some errors.The research shows that the measurement accuracy of small consumer UAV can reach centimeter level with reliable flight control system condition;this condition provides a new measurement method for low-cost,fast,flexible,and accurate terrain information acquisition to geography and ecology researchers.