Abstract:Beginning in the early 1990's, grazing lands once held in common were contracted to individual households in the rangeland regions of China. The resulting fragmentation of rangelands has led to ecological and social problems. As China seeks to address intractable poverty and rangeland degradation, attention has turned to rental, or transfer, of contracted grazing land as a market-based approach to re-aggregating grazing land into larger units that support economies of scale. However, given that many pastoral regions still maintain community customary institutions, what the relationship between market mechanisms and local customary institutions should be in rangeland management needs further analysis. This paper applies comparative case studies of two types of relationships between market mechanisms and customary institutions: (1) market mechanisms that replace customary institutions in the case of Axi village, and (2) market mechanisms that are embedded within customary institutions in Xiareer village. This allows contrast of the impacts of differing approaches on livelihoods, livestock production, and wealth differentiation among pastoral households. We found that there is a higher level of livestock mortality, lower livestock productivity, and higher livestock production cost in Axi Village compared to Xiareer Village. In addition, household asset levels are higher and there is less income differentiation in Xiareer Village. It is concluded that embedding market mechanisms within customary institutions has had notable benefits for the herders of Xiareer Village, because it is a better fit to the coupled pastoral social-ecological system. Based on these findings, we argue that in pastoral communities where the rangeland transfer system for contracted grazing land has not yet been implemented, it is critical to reconsider China's current policy approach to pay greater attention to the innovative management systems being developed in local regions. Instead of considering market-based approaches as oppositional to traditional institutions, options that derive from the interaction of market-based and customary institutions should be considered. (C) 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Informal Institutions and Grassland Protection: Empirical Evidence from Pastoral Regions in China

Determinants of Grassland Use Right Transfer in Institutional Change: Evidence from Pastoral China

Informal Institutions Moderate the Relationship Between Environmental Emotion and Grassland Governance Behavior

How physical and social factors affect village-level irrigation: An institutional analysis of water governance in northern China

Between Social Capital and Formal Governance in Farmer Cooperatives: Evidence from China

Grassland Tenure Reform and Grassland Quality in China

Informal Institutions, Collective Action, and Public Investment in Rural China

Property rights and grassland degradation: A study of the Xilingol Pasture, Inner Mongolia, China

A comprehensive study on non-governmental actors in shaping grassland ecological compensation within legal frameworks

The Impact of Ecological Construction Programs on Grassland Conservation in Inner Mongolia, China

Market-based Grazing Land Transfers and Customary Institutions in the Management of Rangelands: Two Case Studies on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau

Does Nature-Based Solution Sustain Grassland Quality? Evidence from Rotational Grazing Practice in China

Cooperative grassland management practices promoted by land tenure system transformation benefit social-ecological systems of pastoralism on the Qinghai-Tibetan plateau, China

Social Networks, Informal Accountability, and Public Goods Provision in Rural China: A Reassessment

Responses of Grazing Households to Different Levels of Payments for Ecosystem Services

The Grassland Ecological Compensation Policy Drives the Differentiation of Herders’ Livelihoods in Inner Mongolian Desert Grassland

Effect of Village Informal Institutions and Cadre-Mass Relationship for Farmers’ Participation in Rural Residential Environment Governance in China

Social Embeddedness, Power Balance, and Local Governance in China

Distributed Overgrazing: A Neglected Cause of Grassland Degradation in Inner Mongolia

Grassland ecological compensation policy in China improves grassland quality and increases herders’ income

Multiple Social Networks in Grassroots Governance in Rural China