Abstract:Vehicle automation, manifested in self-driving cars, promises to provide safe mobility by reducing human errors. While the testing of automated vehicles (AVs) has improved their performance in recent years, automation technologies face challenges such as uncertainty of safety impacts in mixed traffic with human-driven vehicles. This study aims to examine the gaps in AV safety performance and identify what will be required on a preferential basis for AVs to guarantee an acceptable level of safety performance, especially in mixed traffic, by conducting a thorough analysis of crashes involving levels 2-3 AVs. Based on 260 AV collision reports from California from 2019 to 2021, this study extracts crash-related variables from crash records in a standardized form, crash locations, and, notably, crash narratives reported by AV manufacturers. This study untangles the complex interrelationships among pre-crash conditions, AV driving modes, crash types, and crash outcomes by applying a path-analytic framework with the frequentist and Bayesian approaches. Results show that 51.9 percent of crashes were rear-ends. Particularly, AVs become more vulnerable to rear-end collisions in the automated driving mode than in the conventional mode, given a crash. Additionally, the automated driving mode would not significantly affect the chance of a sideswipe collision, injury, or AV damage levels. Another interesting finding is that manual disengagement is more likely to happen when an AV interacts with a transit vehicle right before a crash occurs while having a negative relationship with injury crashes. Moreover, to reduce injury crashes, AVs would need more thorough testing to adapt to the critical roadway and infrastructure features such as intersections, ramps, and slip lanes; and roadway infrastructure would require improvements to support transportation automation. The risk factors identified in this study can be considered in AV safety assessment scenarios and future operations of mixed traffic. This study demonstrates that AV crash narrative data can be leveraged to improve knowledge of AV safety in mixed traffic.

Human Injury-Based Safety Decision of Automated Vehicles

A Prediction-Uncertainty-Aware Safety Decision-Making Algorithm Towards Injury Risk Minimization under Safety-Critical Scenarios

Safe, Efficient and Socially-Compatible Decision of Automated Vehicles: a Case Study of Unsignalized Intersection Driving

Predicting Autonomous Vehicle Collision Injury Severity Levels for Ethical Decision Making and Path Planning

Risk-anticipatory autonomous driving strategies considering vehicles' weights, based on hierarchical deep reinforcement learning

Advancing investigation of automated vehicle crashes using text analytics of crash narratives and Bayesian analysis

Safe and Adaptive Decision Algorithm of Automated Vehicle for Unsignalized Intersection Driving

An analytic framework using deep learning for prediction of traffic accident injury severity based on contributing factors

How would autonomous vehicles behave in real-world crash scenarios?

Game-based Decision Algorithm for Socially Compatible Automated Driving: a Case Study of Unsignalized Intersection Driving

Three Principles to Determine the Right-of-Way for AVs: Safe Interaction With Humans

A Method for Crash Prediction and Avoidance Using Hidden Markov Models

Summarizing Vehicle Driving Decision-Making Methods on Vulnerable Road User Collision Avoidance

Deep Reinforcement Learning Enabled Decision-Making for Autonomous Driving at Intersections

The typical AV accident scenarios in the urban area obtained by clustering and association rule mining of real-world accident reports

Brain-Inspired Modelling and Decision-making for Human-Like Autonomous Driving in Mixed Traffic Environment

Brain-Inspired Modeling and Decision-Making for Human-Like Autonomous Driving in Mixed Traffic Environment

Application of Machine Learning in Ethical Design of Autonomous Driving Crash Algorithms

Approaching autonomous driving with cautious optimism: analysis of road traffic injuries involving autonomous vehicles based on field test data

Making autonomous vehicle systems human-like: lessons learned from accident experiences in traffic

Ethical Decision Making During Automated Vehicle Crashes