Outdoor Environment Assessment Tool for Existing Neighbourhoods Based on the Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Method

Kang Zhao,Ziling Jiang,Danyang Li,Jian Ge
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2021.108687
IF: 7.093
2021-01-01
Building and Environment
Abstract:Numerous existing neighbourhoods, such as many of those built-in 1980–2000 in China, have poor physical environmental conditions. Supplemented by field investigations, this paper puts forward an outdoor environment evaluation tool designed for existing neighbourhoods based on the multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) method. Evaluation indicators of the acoustic, luminous, and thermal environments and air quality were chosen and classified according to the characteristics of existing neighbourhoods. The weight of each indicator was determined through opinions from both residents and experts. To achieve a comprehensive score, the calculation was carried out based on a multi-level system for neighbourhoods with different conditions/requirements. The proposed methodology was then applied to measure the outdoor environment performance of four existing neighbourhoods in Hangzhou, China. Results showed that, for all neighbourhoods, the outdoor environments were shown to be inadequate regarding acoustic and luminous environments, with improvement potential for the thermal environment and air quality. Corresponding suggestions for renovation and upgrading were put forward. The proposed tool can inform renovation potential of existing neighbourhoods from both residents' and experts’ opinions, diagnosis of outdoor physical environments in four aspects, and development of renovation strategies under different environmental conditions/requirements.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?