Agency Conflicts in Co-Regulation: Evidence from IPO Application Screening in China

Ye Liu,Jingzhe Liu,Wei Ai,Zengxiang Wang,Yunbi An

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.irfa.2022.102131

IF: 8.235

2022-01-01

International Review of Financial Analysis

Abstract:We examine agency conflicts in co-regulation using the unique data on audit firms with partners serving on the Stock Issuance Examination and Verification Committee (SIEVC), referred to here as SIEVC-connected audit firms, in China. We find that audit firms' SIEVC connection helps enhance the likelihood of their client com-panies passing SIEVC's IPO screening. We further demonstrate that to trade off opportunistic gains against reputational and legal costs, SIEVC-connected audit firms tend to work with those IPO applicant companies with overall quality no worse than others. Finally, we show that to seek the greatest possible opportunistic gains and reduce reputational and legal costs, SIEVC-connected audit firms strategically choose to work with the IPO applicant companies with good observable quality and poor unobservable quality. Our findings imply that due to agency conflicts, private entities participating in co-regulation tend to seek their own benefits by helping their connected parties obtain resources. In addition, IPO applicant screening on unobservable quality aggravate agency conflicts and induce more opportunistic behavior on the part of private parties participating in co- regulation. While such opportunistic behavior weakens the fairness of resource allocation, it does not reduce the efficiency of resource allocation.