Abstract:Conventional models of bargaining and reassurance under incomplete information assume that actors' behavioral signals are objectively cooperative or noncooperative. Even if actors are uncertain of each other's preferences, they know what types of actions the other will view as cooperative. Yet on many real‐world issues, cooperation is subjective, and what constitutes a cooperative action is conditional on the receiver's preferences. We present a formal model showing that in these cases, two‐sided incomplete information actually incentivizes honest behavior and facilitates credible signaling. Because uncertain senders do not know whether a particular action will be interpreted as cooperative, they have little incentive to misrepresent, and instead honestly pursue their true goals. Thus, where cooperation is subjective, mutual uncertainty is "offsetting," such that credible signals allow actors to quickly and accurately update their beliefs. We illustrate this logic through a case study of the Sino–Soviet split, and highlight the model's implications for contemporary U.S.–China relations.

Overconfidence and Endogenous Contract Incompleteness

Does Contractual Incompleteness Necessarily Lead to Inefficient Specific Investment?

Incomplete contracts with disparity, uncertainty, information and incentives

Incomplete Contracting Theory: A Survey

Overconfidence,Limited Participation and Asset Price Bubbles

The Overconfident, or the More Informed?

Intensified distortion: Investment decisions with endogenous contracts and time inconsistency

Exploiting overconfidence: optimal contracts with heterogeneous beliefs

Incentive Compensation Based on Managerial Ability and Overconfidence Bias

Hold-Up, Property Rights and Reputation

Compromise, Don't Optimize: Generalizing Perfect Bayesian Equilibrium to Allow for Ambiguity

Effect of Overconfidence on Cournot Competition in the Presence of Yield Uncertainty

The relationship between uncertainty, the contract zone, and efficiency in a bargaining experiment

Incomplete Contract, Incentive Equilibrium in the Exit of Venture Capital and the Control Transfer

Incentive Contracting under Ambiguity Aversion

Risk Aversion, Ambiguity Aversion And The Incentive Problem With Interim Participation Constraints

Offsetting Uncertainty: Reassurance with Two‐Sided Incomplete Information

Does Overconfidence Always Matter for Asset Prices?

Optimism Bias and Incentive Contracts in Portfolio Delegation

Equilibrium contracts and boundedly rational expectations

Contract Design and Self-Control with Asymmetric Information