Performance Feedback and Firms' Relative Strategic Emphasis: the Moderating Effects of Board Independence and Media Coverage

Lulu Cheng,En Xie,Junyi Fang,Nan Mei
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2021.09.021
IF: 11.3
2021-01-01
Journal of Business Research
Abstract:This study investigates how performance feedback--the discrepancy between aspiration and actual performance--relates to firms' relative strategic emphasis on value-creation (VC) versus value-appropriation (VA). With a sample of 7460 firm-year observations collected from 1558 publicly-listed Chinese companies during 2011-2017, we find that negative performance feedback boosts firms' relative strategic emphasis on VC versus VA, while positive performance feedback has an inverted U-shaped effect. Explicitly, a low to medium level of positive performance feedback increases firms' relative emphasis on VC, while a medium to high level of positive feedback decreases it. We find that two monitoring mechanisms-board independence and media coverage-moderate these influences. Specifically, board independence weakens the boosting effect of negative performance feedback and strengthens the inverted U-shaped effect of positive performance feedback; media coverage strengthens the boosting effect of negative performance feedback and weakens the inverted U-shaped effect of positive performance feedback.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?