Abstract:We study a two-alternative voting game where voters' preferences depend on an unobservable world state and each voter receives a private signal correlated to the true world state. We consider the collective decision when voters can collaborate in a group and have antagonistic preferences -- given the revealed world state, voters will support different alternatives. We identify sharp thresholds for the fraction of the majority-type voters necessary for preference aggregation. We specifically examine the majority vote mechanism (where each voter has one vote, and the alternative with more votes wins) and pinpoint a critical threshold, denoted as $\theta_{\texttt{maj}}$, for the majority-type proportion. When the fraction of majority-type voters surpasses $\theta_{\texttt{maj}}$, there is a symmetric strategy for the majority-type that leads to strategic equilibria favoring informed majority decisions. Conversely, when the majority-type proportion falls below $\theta_{\texttt{maj}}$, equilibrium does not exist, rendering the aggregation of informed majority decisions impossible. Additionally, we propose an easy-to-implement mechanism that establishes a lower threshold $\theta^\ast$ (with $\theta^\ast \leq \theta_{\texttt{maj}}$) for both equilibria and informed majority decision aggregation. We demonstrate that $\theta^\ast$ is optimal by proving a general impossibility result: if the majority-type proportion is below $\theta^\ast$, with mild assumptions, no mechanism can aggregate the preferences, meaning that no equilibrium leads to the informed majority decision for any mechanism.

Sequential Agenda Setting with Strategic and Informative Voting

Pivot Versus Signaling in Collective Bargaining

Communication in Collective Bargaining

Monopoly agenda control with privately informed voters

Voting with Public Information.

Who Controls the Agenda Controls the Polity

The Wisdom of Strategic Voting

Voting to persuade

Veto games: Spatial committees under unanimity rule

Strategic behavior in dynamic auctions

Forthcoming in the Economic Journal the Role of Information Revelation in Elimination Contests

The dynamics of strategic voting: pathways to consensus and gridlock

Voting Rights, Agenda Control and Information Aggregation

Epistemic Selection of Costly Alternatives: The Case of Participatory Budgeting

Proportional Aggregation of Preferences for Sequential Decision Making

Strategic Voting in the Context of Negotiating Teams

Aggregation of Antagonistic Contingent Preferences: When Is It Possible?

Bargaining on Behalf of a Constituency

Sequential Deliberation for Social Choice