Female Managers,Institutional Environment and Corporate Charitable Donation——Evidence from Chinese Capital Market
DU Xing-qiang,FENG Wen-tao
2012-01-01
Abstract:Using a sample of Chinese listed firms,this paper empirically examines the influence of female managers on corporate charitable donation.The results show that female managers have a significantly positive impact on corporate charitable donation.In particular,the existence of female manager and the ratio of female managers are significantly positively associated with corporate charitable donation.Moreover,my paper also reveals that the positive association between female managers and corporate charitable donation is attenuated for firms located in provinces with better institutional environment.That is,the better the institutional environment is,the smaller the positive effect of female managers on corporate charitable donation is.This finding implies that there is a substitution relationship between female managers and institutional environment.Above results are robust for a battery of sensitivity tests. San Cong Si De,Qin Nv Gong,and You Fu Gong.These old Chinese sayings reflect the narrow traditional value of Chinese women for thousands of years.However,the economic miracle of reforming and opening up in past 30 years changed the traditional views of the Chinese society towards women.Recent annual reports of Chinese listed firms show that the female managers in the male-dominated business community occupy increasingly important seats.Extant literature indicates that female managers gradually own the right to make recommendations,vote,and even involve in decision-making power(Firth,2007).Female managers can rely on their knowledge to help the company increase creativity,solve problems more effectively and better understand the complexity of the surroundings(Ren & Wang,2010;Jia & Zhang,2011).According to the annual reports,the female managers in the proportion of the management of listed companies in China are also increasing.Female managers have more opportunities to participate in firms' decision-making and become an important and ignored force. In comparison with male managers,female managers are inclined to social responsibility and have stronger oversight motives(Ibrahim & Angelidis,1994;Gul et al.,2011).Especially,women contain a significant difference value orientation from men in ethics(Gillgan,1993).Therefore,female managers can play their own unique and important role on decision-making in corporate charitable donation,which becomes an increasingly frequent and important corporate disclosure.Preston & O'Bannon(1997),Ruf(2001) argues that gains from corporate social responsibility significantly outweigh the costs,and corporate performance will be significantly improved.Extant studies in Chinese background also show that corporate charitable donation helps company win market reputation,enhance market performance and accounting performance(Zhong,2007;Fang,2009).And then,whether and how female managers can influence the corporate charitable donation? The discussion and analysis of this problem will help us further understand the economic consequences and expand the research on corporate charitable donation. The contributions of our study are as follows:(1) To our knowledge,Chinese scholars rarely address the concern about the impact of gender on firms' charitable donations decision-making,so this paper fill this gap and provide incremental empirical evidence based on Chinese background.(2) In line with the reality of contemporary corporations' decision-making,prior studies argue that the decision-making mechanism under the framework of operational diversity requires managers' extensive participation(Kabongo et al.,2011),therefore this paper firstly expands the range of female managers from the directors to all top managers.(3) Taking this unique background in the Chinese stock market into account,this paper further examines the substitution effect between institutional environment and female managers,which expands and enriches extant studies.