On Evidence in Philosophy by William Lycan

Xingming Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/anaa014

2020-01-01

Analysis

Abstract:I always want to read a book that not only shows how contemporary philosophers actually do philosophy but also argues how we should do philosophy. Lycan claims that he has written such a book. Like Lycan’s other writings, this book is engagingly written and clearly argued. I enjoyed it very much and would highly recommend it to those who are interested in the relevant topics. Lycan argues that the goal of philosophy is to achieve reflective equilibrium, not any kind of reflective equilibrium, but the kind of reflective equilibrium where a philosophical theory best explains the data that is common sense, science and our firmest intuitions. In what follows, I will first summarize Lycan’s major argument for this claim. Then, I will briefly explain how each chapter of the book contributes to the argument. Finally, I will offer an alternative picture of philosophy. If this alternative picture is plausible, then...