Does Quality Certification Reduce Quality Risk in Food Supply Chains?

Kangkang Yu,Cheng Qian,Ben Nanfeng Luo,Han Jiang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2019.14107abstract
2019-01-01
Abstract:With increasing concerns regarding food quality and safety, food companies will invest in official quality certification with the aim of enhancing quality assurance as well as reducing quality risk. However, few studies have investigated whether quality certification actually reduces quality risk. Based on normal accident theory and high reliability theory, this study offers competing hypotheses regarding the primary effects that different quality certification will exhibit on quality risk in food supply chains for both internal and external supply chain quality management (SCQM). Furthermore, this study investigates the moderating effects that vertical integration and supply chain efficiency exhibit on these primary certification effects. The study’s hypotheses are tested using regression analyses with the 10-year panel data of 112 listed companies in the agricultural and food industry of China. Results show that, in the food supply chain, quality certification for either internal or external SCQM increases quality risk, which indicates that normal accident theory trumps high reliability theory in this analytical context. Moreover, it is found that vertical integration positively moderates the effect that quality certification for internal SCQM will have on quality risk, while supply chain efficiency negatively moderates the effect that quality certification for external SCQM will have on quality risk. These findings indicate that quality certification for internal SCQM will increase quality risk, especially in companies with high levels of vertical integration. Quality certification for external SCQM will also increase quality risk, but less so when a company’s supply chain is more efficient.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?