How Does Supervisor Negative Feedback Influence Employee Learning? an Attribution Perspective

Lu Xing,Jianmin Sun,Denise Mary Jepsen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2019.10751abstract

2019-01-01

Abstract:Research has provided conflicting evidence of the impact of negative feedback on employee learning. To reconcile the inconsistent understanding, we developed and tested an integrated model of negative feedback by taking an attribution perspective that examines whether, how, and when supervisor negative feedback affects employee engagement in learning activities. We propose that supervisor negative feedback serves as a double-edged sword, with such effects carried through employees’ interpretation of the management goals underlying negative feedback (i.e., feedback motivation attribution). Employees’ core self-evaluation is theorized to moderate the relationships. Results from two-wave survey data of 276 Chinese employees show for employees with high core self-evaluation, supervisor negative feedback has a “bright side”, is positively related to external feedback motivation attribution, which in turn facilitates employee engagement in learning activities. However, for employees with low core self-evaluation, supervisor negative feedback exhibits a “dark side”, it increases internal feedback motivation attribution, which hampers engagement in learning activities. Theoretical and practical implications are discussed.