Abstract:We thank Tang and Ju for their review on statistical inference for univariate response data with nonignorable missing. In this paper, we mainly discuss some issues on longitudinal data with nonignorable dropout. In research areas such as medicine, population health, economics, social sciences and sample surveys, data are often collected from every sampled subject at T time points, which are referred to as longitudinal data. Let Y = (y1, . . . , yT) be aT dimensional vector of the study variable with distribution denoted by p(Y), and X be a q-dimensional time-independent continuous covariate associatedwithY. Our interest is to estimate parameters in p(Y) such as the mean vector E(Y). We consider the situation where X is always observed, but subjects may drop out prior to the end of the study, which results in incomplete Y data. Let R = (r1, . . . , rT) be the vector of response indicators, where rt = 1 if yt is observed and rt = 0 if yt , . . . , yT are not observed. Dropout is ignorable if the propensity p(R | Y ,X) is a function of the observed values (Little & Rubin, 2002), where p(· | ·) is a generic notation for conditional distribution or density. Otherwise, dropout is nonignorable. When missing data are ignorable dropout, Little (1995) presented some well-established methods. However, in practice dropout is often nonignorable (Troxel, Harrington, & Lipsitz, 1998). In this case, for identifiability Wang, Qi, and Shao (2018) assumed that X = (U,Z) with an instrument Z satisfying p(R | Y ,X) = p(R | Y ,U) and that p(Y | U,Z) depends onZ. Furthermore, a parametric dropout propensitymodel is also imposed as follows,

Rejoinder: Statistical Inference for Non-Ignorable Missing-Data Problems: a Selective Review

Stop or Continue Data Collection: A Nonignorable Missing Data Approach for Continuous Variables

Some issues on longitudinal data with nonignorable dropout, a discussion of “Statistical Inference for Nonignorable Missing-Data Problems: A Selective Review” by Niansheng Tang and Yuanyuan Ju

Statistical Inferences for Missing Response Problems Based on Modified Empirical Likelihood

Adaptive Empirical Likelihood Estimation with Nonignorable Nonresponse Data

Full-semiparametric-likelihood-based inference for non-ignorable missing data

Empirical Likelihood-Based Inference in Nonlinear Regression Models with Missing Responses at Random

Empirical Likelihood Inference in Linear Regression with Nonignorable Missing Response

Missing at Random or Not: A Semiparametric Testing Approach

Semiparametric Inference for Estimating Equations with Nonignorably Missing Covariates

Statistical Analysis with Missing Data

Semiparametric Estimating Equations Inference with Nonignorable Nonresponse

Empirical Likelihood for Nonlinear Regression Models with Nonignorable Missing Responses

Nonparametric Inference about Mean Functionals of Nonignorable Nonresponse Data Without Identifying the Joint Distribution

Efficient Multiple-Robust Estimation for Nonresponse Data Under Informative Sampling

Empirical Likelihood for Estimating Equations with Nonignorably Missing Data.

A unified framework of analyzing missing data and variable selection using regularized likelihood

Identifiability and Estimation of Two-Sample Data with Nonignorable Missing Response

The Analysis of Social-Science Data with Missing Values

Handling Nonmonotone Missing Data with Available Complete-Case Missing Value Assumption

A Note on Ising Network Analysis with Missing Data