Abstract:Motivated by the emergence of various corporate social responsibility (CSR) rankings and awards, we study the impacts of distributional social comparison behavior of firms on CSR in a supply chain, consisting of one manufacturer and one retailer. Both the manufacturer and the retailer can choose to make CSR investment, which attracts CSR-concerned consumers. We consider two types of social comparison behavior: ahead seeking that makes one willing to overperform relative to others, and ahead averse that results in underperforming. We find that if the retailer is a large enterprise who has strong negotiation power in the supply chain, his ahead-seeking behavior cannot motivate the up-tier manufacturer to increase CSR investment. In contrast, if the retailer is small, his ahead-seeking behavior can lead to significant increase in the manufacturer’s CSR investment. This is because the increased market share achieved by the small ahead-seeking retailer makes it profitable for the manufacturer to increase CSR investment. Interestingly, the total CSR investment of the supply chain is also higher with the small ahead-seeking retailer than that with the large ahead-seeking retailer. On the other hand, the ahead-averse behavior of the retailer increases the manufacturer’s CSR investment if the retailer is large, whereas it reduces the manufacturer’s investment if the retailer is small. While many contemporary CSR rankings and awards are for large firms in practice, our results suggest that governments and NGOs should pay more attention to small firms, motivating their ahead-seeking behavior or deterring ahead-averse behavior through rankings and awards. Measures to promote consumers’ social consciousness are also helpful to leverage the benefit of ahead-seeking behavior or to offset the negative effect of ahead-averse behavior.

Social Comparison Pressure and Increase in Corporate Philanthropy

Corporate Philanthropy and Corporate Misconduct: Evidence from China

Corporate Philanthropy and Tunneling: Evidence from China

Doing Good Deeds at a Constant Speed

Can Corporate Philanthropy Be Driven from the Bottom to the Top? Evidence from China

Does Family Involvement Make Firms Donate More? Empirical Evidence from Chinese Private Firms

Does Corporate Philanthropy Bring about Corporate Value the Empirical Evidence Using Stakeholder Satisfaction As a Moderating Variable from Listed Companies

Corporate Philanthropy, Brand Equity and Corporate Performance:An Analysis based on Data of China's Listed Companies

Do Employees Support Corporate Philanthropy? Evidence from Chinese Listed Companies

Impacts of Distributional Social Comparison Behavior on Corporate Social Responsibility: Power of the Small

Conflicting Stakeholder Pressures and the Decoupling of Corporate Philanthropy Practices

Competition-Commitment-Compliance: Motivation of Philanthropic Donation in Chinese Firms

Chinese Private Corporate Philanthropy: Social Responsibility, Legitimacy Strategy, and the Role of Political Capital

Corporate philanthropy, political connections, and costs of equity capital

The Strength of Two Hands: Conflicting Stakeholder Pressures and Corporate Philanthropic Giving

Listed Peers' Giving and Corporate Philanthropy: the Motivations to Imitate

Corporate Philanthropy,Marketing Activities and Firm Performance:Considering Industry Competition as a Boundary Condition

To Be Philanthropic when Being International: Evidence from Chinese Family Firms

Environmental Regulation and Corporate Philanthropy: Evidence and Mechanism from China

Too Little or Too Much? Untangling the Relationship Between Corporate Philanthropy and Firm Financial Performance

Research the Impact of Corporate Philanthropy Giving on Firm Financial Performance——Based on the Consumers' Perspective