P1‐222: Auditory Verbal Learning Test is Superior to Rey‐osterrieth Complex Figure Memory for Predicting Progression from Mild Cognitive Impairment to Alzheimer's Disease

Qianhua Zhao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jalz.2015.06.422
2015-01-01
Abstract:To carry meaningful comparisons on results of different research studies on mild cognitive impairment (MCI), it is critical to select an appropriate objective memory test to examine of memory deficit. We aim to refine the operational criteria of amnestic MCI (aMCI) diagnosis on neuropsychological tests that optimally balances the sensitivity and specificity. We focus on 206 non-demented subjects from memory clinic. We then classify each individual as having MCI or subjective cognitive decline (SCD) according to different neuropsychological criteria. By following them longitudinally, clinical outcomes are compared to evaluate the stability of MCI diagnoses and prediction of progression. The delayed recall of auditory verbal learning test (AVLT_DR) identified 116 subjects as MCI, result in the conversion rate as 44% over the roughly 30-month time interval, missed 7.8% incipient AD patients in SCD group who eventually converted to dementia. The delayed recall of complex figure test (CFT_DR) identified fewer MCI patients than AVLT_DR and misdiagnosed more preclinical AD patients as cognitive normal. Criteria requiring deficits in both tests produced higher conversion rate in MCI group, but resulted in higher misdiagnosis rate simultaneously. The one test (AVLT_DR deficit) criterion had the largest area under the curve. AVLT is superior to CFT in the stability of diagnoses and prediction of progression. In the clinical setting, the “one test” criterion AVLT has similar sensitivity to both-deficits methods, and is optimal in balancing sensitivity and specificity. Receiver Operating Characteristic Curves Analysis MCI1: AVLT (+), subjects score below the cut-off score of AVLT_DR; MCI3: CFT subjects score below the cut-off score of CFT_DR; MCI13: concordant group, subjects score below the cut-off score in both tests (+); MCI 14: Either test score below the cut-off score in either AVLT_DR or CFT_DR. Kaplan Meier Survival .Analysis.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?