China's Quest for Political Legitimacy: The New Equity - Enhancing Politics
Emilie Tran
2011-10-01
Abstract:Guo Baogang China's Quest for Political Legitimacy: The New Equity - Enhancing Politics, Lanham, Lexington Books, 2010, 216 pp.How does the Communist Party of China (CPC) manage to keep its hold on power and retain legitimacy after 60 years of leading the country under monopoly control? How to explain the popular backing it enjoys - perhaps now more than ever - as empirical studies show,(1)despite the exponential rise in the number of protests - 180,000 in 2010, or four times that in the previous decade and twice the number in 2006? (2)For Guo Baogang, this is neither mysterious nor miraculous but can be explained with a change in analytical perspective. That the CPC is not en- dorsed through free and competitive elections does not render it illegiti- mate, in his view; on the contrary, the Party's longevity and popularity should make social science scholars rethink the legitimacy concept. Right from the outset, the book seeks to build a new analytical framework for better grasping the legitimacy of political authority in the Chinese case.While it contains some shocking errors such as spelling the Chinese Pres- ident's name as Hu Jingtao (p. 29 and 44), China's Quest for Political Le- gitimacyconcisely and in a fluid style reviews the developments in and of post-Deng era politics. While it adds no new facts, the book makes for a ready reckoner on the last three decades' political history and is indispen- sable for anyone interested in contemporary China. After noting the differ- ent political philosophies holding sway since the late 1970s - from Deng Xiaoping's pragmatism to the new social contract at the end of the Hu- Wen era - (Chapter 2), Guo goes over the characteristics of the three gen- erations of leaders who have led the country since Mao's death - "revolu- tionary modernisers" steered by Deng, the generation of technocrats headed by Jiang Zemin, and finally the "lost generation" (Chapter 3). Using the examples of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference and the National People's Congress (Chapter 4), as well as several scandals and conflicts resolved through dialogue between local governments and those concerned (Chapter 5), Guo shows that formal or informal consultations have multiplied and been institutionalised, helping represent the view- points of interest groups as well as of the public at large. Both at the top of the Party-state and at the level of the common citizen, there are nas- cent signs of a deliberative state, even a deliberative democracy in China. Inspired by John Rawls and Jurgen Habermas, theoreticians of deliberative democracy (3) such as Joseph Bessette (who coined the term deliberative democracy(4)or discursive democracy) and Joshua Cohen(5)hold that the legitimacy of a policy decision resides first and foremost in the process of deliberation and less in the fact of being voted upon, contrary to democ- racy in its liberal form.Guo pursues his reasoning by citing other examples of interactions be- tween the Party-state and its local representatives and the citizens in each of the three major socio-economic undertakings that concern the leader- ship and could imperil the country's future: the environmental "new deal" (Chapter 6), labour relations (Chapter 7), and healthcare reform (Chapter 8). While there, the author highlights the juggling of two contradictory but nevertheless complementary tendencies: the policy of promoting effi- ciency and that stressing equity. The Party-state has successively favoured one or the other. Now the balance of power in itself reflects the regime's dynamism. No need for free and competitive elections in order to be deemed legitimate. By allowing more dialogue, consultation, and negotia- tion at all levels of the politico-social structure, the regime has entered an- other cycle of transformation aimed at strengthening and consolidating its legitimacy. In fact, conflicts are being resolved as increasing numbers of citizens, becoming active and feeling newly empowered, come to acknowl- edge, through engagement of their deliberative capacity, that the all-see- ing and well-meaning regime is improving and doing its best while facing innumerable challenges to remake itself, thereby bestowing a veneer of le- gitimacy on one-party rule. …
Sociology,Political Science