Abstract:AbstractStudies suggest that students’ prior performance can shape subsequent teacher evaluations, but the magnitude of reputational effects and their implications for educational inequality remain unclear. Existing scholarship presents two major perspectives that exist in tension: do teachers primarily use reputational information as a temporary signal that is subsequently updated in response to actual student performance? Or do teachers primarily use reputational information as a filter that biases perception of subsequent evidence, thus crystallizing student reputations and keeping previously poor-performing students stuck in place? In a field experiment, we recruited a random sample of 832 junior high school teachers from the second-most populous province of China to grade a sequence of four essays written by the same student, and we randomly assign both the academic reputation of the student and the quality of the essays produced. We find that (1) reputational information influences how teachers grade, (2) teachers rely on negative information more heavily than positive information, and (3) negative reputations are crystallized by a single behavioral confirmation. These results suggest that students can escape their prior reputations, but to do so, they must contradict them immediately, with a single confirmation sufficient to crystallize a negative reputation.

Do Professional Rankings Affect Analyst Behavior? Evidence from a Regression Discontinuity Design

Games for Attention: Evidence from Analysts’ Earnings Forecasts for U.S.-Listed Foreign Firms

A Star is Born: Star Analyst Voting and Analyst Research

Do changes in star selection criteria affect analyst behaviour?

Rankings and Risk-Taking in the Finance Industry

The Effect of Social Skills on Analyst Performance

Analyzing the Analysts: the Effects of Technical and Social Skills on Analyst Performance and Careers

Winners and losers in investment competition – Experimental study

Can leagues mitigate the demoralisation effect of rank feedback? A randomized controlled trial

CEO Awards and Financial Misconduct

Does Product Market Competition Influence Analyst Coverage and Analyst Career Success?

Analyst teams

The Superiority and Disciplining Role of Independent Analysts

The Macbeth Factor: The Dark Side of Achievement‐driving Analysts

Analyst Career Concerns, Effort Allocation, and Firms’ Information Environment

Does Bold Forecast After Job Change Improve Forecast Accuracy? Evidence From Korean Sell‐Side Analysts

Rankers, Rankees, & Rankings: Peeking into the Pandora's Box from a Socio-Technical Perspective

Analysts' forecast anchoring and discontinuous market reaction: evidence from China

Strategic Ranking

Stuck in Place? A Field Experiment on the Effects of Reputational Information on Student Evaluations

Discipline Rankings and University Admission Attractiveness: Quasi-Natural Experimental Evidence from China