Building Energy Efficiency: Passive Technology or Active Technology?
Xianting Li,Chong Shen,Chuck W. F. Yu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1420326x17719157
2017-01-01
Indoor and Built Environment
Abstract:Building sector accounts for a significant part of total energy consumption. In Europe, almost 40% of energy use is by residential and commercial buildings. Space conditioning accounts for 40% to 60% of building energy end use in European countries. In the USA, the use of heating, ventilating, air-conditioning (HVAC) systems contribute to 50% of energy use in buildings which is about 20% of their total energy consumption. In Middle East, over 70% of building energy is consumed by cooling systems. China, as one of the biggest developing countries, has even more striking data. From 1996 to 2012, the building energy use in China has grown from 259 million ton of standard coal equivalent (Mtce) to 690 Mtce. No doubt the worldwide energy demand of buildings will continuously increase in the near future due to the development of economy and rise of occupants’ comfort demand. Various techniques have been implemented to improve the building energy efficiency. Traditional air-conditioning methods, such as heat pumps and boilers, are mostly active strategies. They have been developed for more than one century. Recent progresses include optimized cycle design and advanced cycle elements (e.g. working fluid). In addition, the improvement of compressor technology and hybrid system contributes to the efficiency of heat pumps. However, active strategies are faced with some insurmountable limitations. The coefficient of performance (COP) of a heat pump can hardly exceed 6, while the combustion efficiency of a boiler is definitely lower than 100%. The energy use of active strategies could be kept at a high level mainly because they directly consume high-grade energy such as electricity and fossil energy. Actually, the use of heat pump and boiler in HVAC is to overcome a relatively large difference between indoor and outdoor temperatures (e.g. 10 C in summer and 20 C in winter). Inevitably, this would lead to relatively low energy efficiency of the whole system. The radiant heating and cooling (RHC) systems have gained popularity due to their contribution to a higher thermal comfort of building occupants and lower energy use. RHC systems are energy efficient because they are able to utilize the hightemperature cooling and low-temperature heating. Nevertheless, most RHC systems still require heat pumps or boilers for cooling or heating with a consumption of considerably high-grade energy. The small cooling/heating intensity and slow system response could also limit the wider application of RHC systems in buildings. Passive strategies are more energy-efficient technologies for application in buildings. These have a much longer history associated with their use in buildings than active strategies. Early passive technologies, such as cave dwellings, kang, hypocaust, etc. existed more than thousands of years. Now many people in the building design profession are focusing on passive strategies such as sun shading, insulation, interior garden, water features, atrium space, natural ventilation, etc., for reducing thermal load in indoor environments. The performance criteria for passive buildings in China have been discussed by Xu et al., previously. Improving the thermal resistance of an envelope is crucial to reduce the building energy use. Up to now, increasing the thickness of insulation layer is still one of the most common approaches to improve the thermal performance of a wall. Since the 1970s, the thickness of insulation has doubled in northern Europe. Thick envelopes, however, would increase investment and require additional materials and building areas, and would be difficult to apply in high-rise buildings. The renovation of the insulation materials may be a problem because their life expectancy is shorter than that of the building. The fire safety of insulation materials could also limit their application. In addition, the thermal insulation integrated with walls would have a high risk of condensation in humid and cold regions. An over-insulated wall could increase the building cooling load because it has a negative impact on the heat dissipation of envelope when ambient environment