Exploring The Causes Of Cheating In Government Performance Measurement In China: Findings From A Public Survey

Xu Yan-Qing,Zhou Zhi-Ren
2015-01-01
Abstract:Gaming or strategic behavior has been a wide spread phenomenon in public sector performance measurement all over the world. Consequently, tremendous efforts have been made to explore the causes of and countermeasures against cheating in the literature. While deliberate inaccuracy of performance information has been a problem perplexing the Chinese local governments for many years, no systematic efforts were taken to address the issue, let alone in-depth empirical research.Drawing on the literature we proposed an analytical framework to explore the driving forces behind cheating, including five headline factors such as social norms, task difficulty, acceptance of the performance measurement system, external supervision, and motivation structure. Then paying special attention to the Chinese contexts, a total of 16 sub-factors were developed around the five headline factors.A questionnaire survey of 257 MPA students was conducted to test the framework model. It was found that of the five headline factors, social norms and insufficient external supervision were regarded as the primary causes of cheating, while task difficulty (excessive targets) was the least important. These are basically in line with the literature. Some interesting variations were found with regard to the relative importance of sub-factors. Linking to the Chinese contextual features, we provide some explanations for these differences between China and other countries.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?